A deal for Alex Smith has been completed

[yseJ]

You dont even know what you're arguing anymore. One sentence your against down the field passing and referring it to something I "fap" to...to the reason Harbaugh making the switch was because Kaep throws the ball better down the field.

no, you just dont want to understand it, either because youre stupid or because you dont want to accept the notion

alex=limited mistakes
kaep=limited mistakes+can make more throws and dangerous with the legs

my point is that you can be a good qb without being a great downfield passer.
you cant be a good qb without minimizing your mistakes.

and sometimes you get both, which are elite qbs. rodgers is a game manager who limits his mistakes.... who can make all the throws.

 

[yseJ]

youve got no ground to stand on here tho

when jim harbaugh says that qbs #1 job is to take care of the ball and trip mcnealy says its to throw big passes and make plays and carry the offense...guess who Im gonna go with

 

[Trip]

youve got no ground to stand on here tho

when jim harbaugh says that qbs #1 job is to take care of the ball and trip mcnealy says its to throw big passes and make plays and carry the offense...guess who Im gonna go with

yet Harbaugh had that guy and benched him

 

[#1 pick]

no, you just dont want to understand it, either because youre stupid or because you dont want to accept the notion

alex=limited mistakes
kaep=limited mistakes+can make more throws and dangerous with the legs

my point is that you can be a good qb without being a great downfield passer.
you cant be a good qb without minimizing your mistakes.

and sometimes you get both, which are elite qbs. rodgers is a game manager who limits his mistakes.... who can make all the throws.

Or Alex just is average

 

[Trip]

Christian Ponder limits his mistakes and takes what the defense gives him!

Andrew Luck takes too many chances. Give me Ponder.

 

[#1 pick]

GT was running an option and every pass they had was basically a gotcha play.

Hill wasnt beating coverage down the field

Breh, what are you talking about. Hill can go over the top, he just too raw of a route runner and it's not like Flacco is throwing to him, it's Sanchez.

 

[#1 pick]

Christian Ponder limits his mistakes and takes what the defense gives him!

Andrew Luck takes too many chances. Give me Ponder.

Ponder makes plays at times. He's just still learning, I still think he will be an elite WCO QB. Luck issues is those long developing routes. Now that he has his OC from college, they will rape you within 15 yards again.

 

[tremonthustler1]

GT was running an option and every pass they had was basically a gotcha play.

Hill wasnt beating coverage down the field

He's capable of doing that though. That will come together with time. It's the same system that produced Demaryius Thomas. How did he look his first 2 years? How does he look now with time and a real QB?

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

Love how salty Alex Smith makes people

Glad he's getting his shot to start elsewhere

 

[Trip]

and sometimes you get both, which are elite qbs. rodgers is a game manager who limits his mistakes.... who can make all the throws.

ok.

If thats what you want to call a game manager. We just have different definitions.

By this definition, game managers are the guys winning Super Bowls.

 

[MarloStanfield]

Breh, what are you talking about. Hill can go over the top, he just too raw of a route runner and it's not like Flacco is throwing to him, it's Sanchez.

Like Hill doesn't drop every thing thrown to him

 

[LastEmperor2k2]

Like Hill doesn't drop every thing thrown to him

I bet you look cute in that #6 authentic jersey

 

[MarloStanfield]

I bet you look cute in that #6 authentic jersey

So I've been told

 

[JLova]

Love how salty Alex Smith makes people

Glad he's getting his shot to start elsewhere

You could say the same thing about Sanchez.

 

[yseJ]

Or Alex just is average

Ive never disputed that.