Adam Silver says changes coming to Hack-A-Shaq rule

mbewane

Knicks: 93 til infinity
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
18,942
Reputation
4,039
Daps
54,202
Reppin
Brussels, Belgium
You need to send that letter to Silver breh... and truthfully we can't go on a rant about every league and their problems. My only argument is that they'll always be players who can't make free throws. Always have been and always will into the future. Should they be better.. hell yes they should be better but it is what it is.. and the exploit/cheat code has gotten out of hand and you might not follow other leagues but others do

I hear you, it's just that I can't get behind something that is basically rewarding mediocrity, and don't understand anyone who does. And the big difference with the Shaq era is that Shaq was basically the only elite player who had this major flaw. As I said, Malone and Duncan were abad or average free throw shooters, they worked on it. Why can't we expect the same from guys (this generation) that are probably already making more than both in that era? Have some pride in what you do. Now you have various All-Star level players who canet make FTs, that's ALL on them. shyt the Davis brothers, Anthony MAson, Dennis Rodman and all those bruisers could make FTs and now we're protecting these guys?

The league has done enough itself against the integrity of its own sport (rewarding floppers, calling touch fouls, etc) to act surprised by this shyt now. And it's the coaches who keep these players in knowing damn well their weaknesses will be exploited.
 
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
3,965
Reputation
390
Daps
12,486
Kornheiser from PTI proposed a pretty good idea. Any off ball foul within the first 45 mins the fouled players coach gets to select who they like to shoot. In the last 3 minutes then that player who gets fouled has to shoot em. If you can't make them during the clutch :camby:
 

pete clemenza

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
36,445
Reputation
3,324
Daps
88,266
Reppin
Cali
I hear you, it's just that I can't get behind something that is basically rewarding mediocrity, and don't understand anyone who does. And the big difference with the Shaq era is that Shaq was basically the only elite player who had this major flaw. As I said, Malone and Duncan were abad or average free throw shooters, they worked on it. Why can't we expect the same from guys (this generation) that are probably already making more than both in that era? Have some pride in what you do. Now you have various All-Star level players who canet make FTs, that's ALL on them. shyt the Davis brothers, Anthony MAson, Dennis Rodman and all those bruisers could make FTs and now we're protecting these guys?

The league has done enough itself against the integrity of its own sport (rewarding floppers, calling touch fouls, etc) to act surprised by this shyt now. And it's the coaches who keep these players in knowing damn well their weaknesses will be exploited.
I get that but look at where we're heading with this sh*t
GIFnoel.gif
:martin:

I agree with not bailing out bad free throw shooters but this type sh*t right here is bad for the game
 

MAKAVELI25

the heir apparent
Supporter
Joined
Jun 21, 2012
Messages
19,023
Reputation
5,695
Daps
75,401
Reppin
#ByrdGang
I'm saying...these dudes are supposed to be the best players in the world and the league has to bail them out because they can't make FREE THROWS? :dahell:

That dumb nikka @Goatpoacher was trying to act like its a tremendous burden to ask a professional basketball player to hit at least 50%. nikka, you're supposed to be one of the best in the fukking world :mindblown:
 

dh86

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
24,148
Reputation
951
Daps
54,508
Reppin
Detroit
Kornheiser from PTI proposed a pretty good idea. Any off ball foul within the first 45 mins the fouled players coach gets to select who they like to shoot. In the last 3 minutes then that player who gets fouled has to shoot em. If you can't make them during the clutch :camby:
So in the last 3 mins of playoff games you want it to last for a half hour of chasing and hugging guys 30 feet from the basket? That's even more farcical. That's like not allowing for a pinch hitter for pitchers in the last 3 innings.
 

dh86

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
24,148
Reputation
951
Daps
54,508
Reppin
Detroit
That dumb nikka @Goatpoacher was trying to act like its a tremendous burden to ask a professional basketball player to hit at least 50%. nikka, you're supposed to be one of the best in the fukking world :mindblown:

A basketball team is composed of players of various skill sets forming a unit. An offensive lineman can't kick an extra point in football either. Does a pitcher batting .100 make him a bad baseball player? I doubt Barry Bonds could throw a curve ball either. Trash?
 

MAKAVELI25

the heir apparent
Supporter
Joined
Jun 21, 2012
Messages
19,023
Reputation
5,695
Daps
75,401
Reppin
#ByrdGang
A basketball team is composed of players of various skill sets forming a unit. An offensive lineman can't kick an extra point in football either. Does a pitcher batting .100 make him a bad baseball player? I doubt Barry Bonds could throw a curve ball either. Trash?

It says a lot about how fukking dumb you are that you thought this was a good analogy.
 
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
3,965
Reputation
390
Daps
12,486
So in the last 3 mins of playoff games you want it to last for a half hour of chasing and hugging guys 30 feet from the basket? That's even more farcical. That's like not allowing for a pinch hitter for pitchers in the last 3 innings.
:dwillhuh: Half hour? The game isn't even extended by a half hour with the initial rules. An average position is around 18-20 seconds. Last time I checked even if you allow it for every single possession, which won't be the case because the coach will take the player out if he keeps missing, the game will at most be extended 10 mins.
 

XII

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
14,031
Reputation
5,530
Daps
64,243
After 30 long years the Detroit Pistons finally get a rule change to go their way :wow:
 

mbewane

Knicks: 93 til infinity
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
18,942
Reputation
4,039
Daps
54,202
Reppin
Brussels, Belgium
I get that but look at where we're heading with this sh*t
GIFnoel.gif
:martin:

I agree with not bailing out bad free throw shooters but this type sh*t right here is bad for the game

Totally agree breh. But for me that's no different than giving free throws to a Harden that goes in the lane and throws his arms around and is rewarded with two FTs. Yet that is celebated in todays NBA. Same with a defensive player flopping and being rewarded with an offensive foul on the other player. That's as bad for the game as this bs, but you can adress those two issues I bring up without protecting mediocrity.

This bs (we all agree it's ridiculous) that Noel did does not happen if Drummond (I assume it's Drumond) is a decent FT shooter. You don't see anyone doing that to a Blake Giffin (who was an average FT shooter early on) or to Robin Lopez. The reason we see this bs is poor FT shooters.
 

Illin Degenerate

All Star
Joined
Jun 14, 2012
Messages
2,240
Reputation
394
Daps
3,716
Reppin
NULL
I mean if it's an off-ball foul they should just allow the coach to pick a shooter :yeshrug:
it needs to be the same for the entire game, none of this under 5 minutes or 2 minutes different rules crap, or extra punitive free throw plus the ball back bs. all the other suggestions (technicals, extra free throws) open things up for subjectivity and the refs to screw up even more games, this is almost fool proof.
 
Top