yseJ
Empire strikes back
even this is not true at all
kevin kolb career in arizona has been significantly better statitically, than in philadelphia
doug pederson is a bum who had a horrible year and so did mike mcmahon
youre grasping at straws here
Alex Smith Wants $18 million dollars per year
- Thread starter kevin arnold
- Start date
kevin kolb career in arizona has been significantly better statitically, than in philadelphia
doug pederson is a bum who had a horrible year and so did mike mcmahon
youre grasping at straws here
yseJ
Empire strikes back
I think alex smith is a serviceable and good enough qb in the league, you think hes garbage. clearly if you say hes trash Im going to refute that.
I never, EVER caped for him
the difference is you think qbs win games, and I think you can win the sb with a 'game manager' like chad pennington. and Id take a game manager like pennington over an erratic big armed dumb qb like late favre, stafford or cutler
You guys don't understand how starved kc has been for good qb play. Trent Green has been their best qb since Montanna 
Now that they've got someone mediocre in there, they're going to overpay him. Just coz it's kc...
Now that they've got someone mediocre in there, they're going to overpay him. Just coz it's kc...
But if you feel that way then what do you think about Kaep about to ge this big contract? Would you let him go so you can sign Matt Flynn and spend the rest of the money on defense and running game?
yseJ
Empire strikes back
He IS garbage. A #1 pick who has underwhelming career numbers. Just like Bradford is garbage.
amerson was a cb for yall wasnt he and he can still play fs
perry riley ? trash
So someone who you don't even know about is considered trash?
You clearly don't know what you're talking about.
yseJ
Empire strikes back
I would let alex smith go if Im in KC, easily.
thats what yall fail to understand, Id boot his ass to the moon right away hed demand this much $
I actually AGREE with letting him go. its just Andy loves him and he won't. he traded those picks for alex to get him. I would never trade a boatload of picks for a player, not even brady, peyton or anyone else
yseJ
Empire strikes back
underwhelming career numbers and status of #1 pick doesnt make him garbage, his last 3 seasons were GOOD seasons and perfectly good to win any football title there is.
bradford isnt garbage either
feelosofer
#ninergang
For better or worse, Alex Smith is an 8 year veteran who has basically been a starter for the vast majority of his career, he's smart, makes solid reads, and while he won't make that circus throw, he won't bury you with poor decisions. The defense, got exposed late in the season and in the playoffs. While I don't think Alex Smith is worth 18 milly, it doesn't matte, keeping him on the roster at least for the next 2 to 3 years is important to the long term success of the team. Everything else can be done though drafts and free agency.
But i'm asking what you think about Kaep about to get 18+ a year since you don't think qb's win games.
yseJ
Empire strikes back
I thought you already knew the answer
yes
but matt flynn is utter garbage to the point he actually loses you games. signing a half-decent stopgap qb for 5-6m would work best imo
heres some of my quotes from the 49er thread re: kaep
why isnt it 'practical' ?
only because qb position is holy cow status for no real reason. no one ever thinks its impractical to do this to any other position
we made 3 nfcs and a sb with alex smith in a new offense, a 1st year starter with like 6 starts under his belt and a second year starter
the hags nearly made nfc game appearance last year with a rookie and then won it all with a second year player this year
as long as defense plays on the same level, we'll be always be in contention. and when it doesn't, no qb will help us.
He'll have to prove to be worth it as far as I'm concerned fukk that's the bullshyt.
If he's top 15 he's 15