All-Time Squad for each NFL team...who wins?

[Red Money]

Ravens

That 2000 Defense plus Lamar and Henry They going to be thin at WR but with Ogden blocking for them Lamar will have plenty of time

What's wrong with Priest Holmes & Jamal Lewis?

Henry is kinda recency bias....

 

[Red Money]

Ravens

That 2000 Defense plus Lamar and Henry They going to be thin at WR but with Ogden blocking for them Lamar will have plenty of time

Derrick Mason, Anquon Boldin and Steve Smith with the physicality and aggression could find a way to hang in any era....

Throw in Torrey Smith to take the top off.....


Ravens better off than y'all think....

 

[IsThatBrothaMouzone?]

I respect the players of generations ago, but how on earth are people saying the Packers? Probably more than half of the players being mentioned were born before 1940 and played before (and after) the merger.

They are not holding a candle to the 49er's for this thread. I don't see where it's really debatable with those two teams. I think the 49er's are multiple tiers above.

I'm looking at it in terms of "relativity." So an All-Pro HOFer from 1962 is judged by how dominant he was in his era versus an All-Pro HOFer in 1992 or 2012 etc. That way it gives balance to legacy versus modern times.

Otherwise it would just be based on the best franchises in the last 20-25 years. Patriots are a good example where if you just judge off the Brady/Belichick years....they rate at the top....but if you expand and look at their whole history, they're not on the level of other franchises when you factor in depth of talent over many decades.

 

[IsThatBrothaMouzone?]

Yeah, it's them and I don't really see the argument against them. You have arguably the two greatest WR's in NFL history along with a QB that was considered the GOAT until Brady came along, and their second string QB is a two time NFL MVP. .

Their OL is good, but Dallas has a better line plus better RBs (Emmitt/Dorsett/Zeke/Herschel).

Aikman and Staubach are closer to Montana/Young than any Niners RB is to the Cowboys stable.

WR?

Jerry >>> everyone else

But Jerry & T.O. versus Irvin, Pearson, Bob Hayes, CeeDee and Dez??? Also Dallas gets T.O. too so that's a wash.

Witten >> any Niners TE and we aren't including Novacek or Ditka; Ditka being HOF

 

[IsThatBrothaMouzone?]

I'm not saying they'd be the best, but I think the Buccaneers can be up there too. They don't have the best WR's, but Evans/Jackson/Galloway/Godwin isn't terrible.

And, they have an absurd defensive-line with Sapp, Rice, McCoy, and Selmon. Then they have Brooks/David/Nickerson at LB with Barber and Lynch in the secondary.

That front seven in absurd.

Since Brady played 3 years with Tampa, y'all get the older version of him.

Imagine the 90s/early 00s Bucs defense + Brady + Evans + Warrick Dunn/Mike Alstott.....


Honestly that team would be a tough matchup.

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

The all time colts is FILTHY btw when you run thru them. Sleeper team.

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Herschel

You’d be better off putting Demarco Murray in over him.

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Deion & Ronnie Lott at their peaks in the secondary

Deion only played one season in SF. He wouldn’t count

 

[jflores]

NY Giants front all time 7 would be pretty stout.

 

[Hey_zeus]

Lowkey the Rams

Good luck blocking the fearsome foursome and Aaron Donald. Night train Lane clotheslin' mfs in the secondary.

Prime Kurt Warner...Then you got dikkerson/Faulk/Gurley behind that GSOT line with Pace. Cupp and Iassac Bruce.

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

Lowkey the Rams

Good luck blocking the fearsome foursome and Aaron Donald. Night train Lane clotheslin' mfs in the secondary.

Prime Kurt Warner...Then you got dikkerson/Faulk/Gurley behind that GSOT line with Pace. Cupp and Iassac Bruce.

Colts vs Rams is a sleeper all time Superbowl pick

 

[Hey_zeus]

Colts vs Rams is a sleeper all time Superbowl pick

I almost went Colts. They got the 4 pre modern prototype skill guys with Unitas, Raymond Berry, John Mackey, Lenny Moore. As backups to Peyton era. Sp000ky offense.

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

The all time colts is FILTHY btw when you run thru them. Sleeper team.

QB - Peyton Manning / Johnny Unitas / Andrew Luck (insane top 3, only Packers comes close)
RB - Edge, Erick dikkerson, Marshall Faulk
WR - Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Ty Hilton, Raymond Berry
TE - Dallas Clark
T - Tarik Glenn
G - Ryan Lilja
C - Jeff Saturday
G - Chris Hinton
T - Bob Vogel
DE - Dwight Freeny
DE - Bubba Smith
DT - Art Donovan
LB - cato June
LB - Robert Mathis
LB - Gary Brackett
S - Bob Sanders
Cb - vontae davis
Cb - ray Buchanan, marlin Jackson
K - Adam vinateri
P - pat mcafee

That RB tandem and QB depth is pretty unrivaled

 

[3Rivers]

What we think @General Mills ?

QB: Big Ben/Bradshaw/Stewart
RB: Le'Veon Bell/ Jerome Bettis
FB: Franco Harris
WR: AB/Ward/Stallworth/Swann/Holmes/Burress
TE: Miller/Cunningham/Green
LT: Kolb/Jackson
LG: Faneca
C: Mike Webster/Dermontti Dawson/Pouncey
RG: Mullins/DeCastro
RT: Brown/Ilkin

FS: Wagner/Clark/Perry
SS: Polamalu/Shell/Lake
CB: Woodson/Blount/Taylor/Butler/Williams
LOLB: Ham/Woodley/Greene/Russell
MLB: Lambert/Farrior/Kirkland/Timmons
ROLB: Harrison/Watt/Lloyd/Porter
DE: Greenwood/White/Smith/Keisel
DT:Greene/Holmes/Stautner/Heyward/Hampton

K: Anderson
P: Walden

KR: Randel El
PR: Holmes

 

[Mantis Toboggan M.D.]

I’m gonna go with the ravens of course. Imagine the modern day offense with Ogden, Birk, and Yanda on the line with a defense that has Ray, Ed, Woodson, McAllister, Ngata, Scott, Suggs, Pryce, & Hamilton with Billick, Rex, Marvin Lewis, & Monken coaching both sides of the ball. That team isn’t losing.


Low key the rams have a great one. Basically the greatest show on turf era teams but with Aaron Donald in place of one of the defensive tackles along with Deacon jones and night train lane.