At this point it is what it is, Aaron Rodgers is nowhere near the GOAT discussion

[Smokin Rider]

U talking playoff arod from 2011 to 2013. Since then, he been clutch and balling until his defense and team turns ass into the NFC ship or divisional round. This dude aint losing no close games, this dude is losing games where his D cant stop a nose bleed. Muthafukkas be breaking team records when they face the Packers defense in the playoffs


Let me just say this real quick. Rodgers is not the same god tier elit QB he used to be. Hes at fault as well for this loss. But,u plug in any damn QB into this Packers team and they too will not over come or keep pace with this defense. ANY QB.

I understand he's a great breh and his defense is bad but you ain't have to quote me twice with 3 different paragraphs. I trusted Favre's fukkery filled games more than Rodger's nonchalantness

I'm no Packer fan but whether you think Rodgers is better or Favre, it's close. People forget how good Favre was

 

[Ineedmoney504]

The same peyton who has a losing record in the playoffs? The same peyton who is ass cheeks in the playoffs yet his TEAM still wins?

yes the same Manning has been to 4 different Super Bowls, with 4 different coach staffs, 4 different WR corps, 4 different running back groups, 4 different defenses and won 2. Peyton is like 2nd in every playoff stat. Rodgers is a career loser at this point.

 

[bear27]

Won the same amount of playoff games this season as kirk did

 

[Tres Leches]

He’s Big Ben with wack coaches

 

[UserNameless]

That's why most talented doesnt mean shyt. Been telling Rodgers stans on this site for years that a young buck us gonna take that mantle in .2. GOAT has lasting value. Gonna take a career of unprecedented excellence to take that title

repped.

 

[JLova]

yes the same Manning has been to 4 different Super Bowls, with 4 different coach staffs, 4 different WR corps, 4 different running back groups, 4 different defenses and won 2. Peyton is like 2nd in every playoff stat. Rodgers is a career loser at this point.

The same guy who played subpar in those super bowls and was lucky enough to have a good enough D to carry him to 2 wins? That Peyton?

Watch more games. Dan Marino is GOAT level, y’all would be calling him hot garbage. How many times did his squad get blown the fukk out in the playoffs? Y’all are weird man. It’s ok to criticize a qb but y’all acting like every game is a referendum on that QB. Defence wins championships. Think about that for a second.

 

[FabTrey]

 

[Ineedmoney504]

The same guy who played subpar in those super bowls and was lucky enough to have a good enough D to carry him to 2 wins? That Peyton?

Watch more games. Dan Marino is GOAT level, y’all would be calling him hot garbage. How many times did his squad get blown the fukk out in the playoffs? Y’all are weird man. It’s ok to criticize a qb but y’all acting like every game is a referendum on that QB. Defence wins championships. Think about that for a second.

He didn’t play subpar in either. He did what the teams needed him to do vs lite teams. He also had a bunch of shoot outs his team loss for him in his playoff career. Had weak run defense his entire times with colts and would sometimes barley see the field

and every super bowl he went to had to get thru Brady and a elite pats defense also.

and being honest with Rodgers lucky to have won one ship, if the mike Vick wasn’t hobbled with the eagles that year he wouldn’t have beat them either. Dude gets nothing but excuses, no reason you should be down 30 in the first half a elite qb, no excuses, and it ain’t like he wasn’t seeing the ball. He was turning it over when he had it or not doing nothing with it. We seen great qbs rip up elite defense with average offenses, and we also seen elite qbs make trash WRs and tight ends look wild elite, Rodgers elite hasnt made one WR or te look really good that wasn’t all that like say brady, Brees and Manning did. Every year it was a different guy looking good.

Rodgers get new guys, high draft picks and other stuff and never make them better. It’s on him

and you blaming manning for getting there and looking average when this bum can’t even get there

 

[UserNameless]

Y'all talking like his career is over.

if he doesn’t force a trade, then for all intents and purposes, his career is likely over because Green Bay isn’t gonna be able to give him what he needs . It’s highly likely ARod peaked a decade ago with that one SuperBowl win.


And he isn’t as dynamic as he used to be.

he can always stat pad for a few more years, tho

 

[JLova]

How many games has Brady won when his D gave up 40 points in the playoffs. I’ll help. ZERO. And before you talk about picks, Brady has won several playoff games while turning the ball over a lot.

Again, Rodgers deserves his fair share of the blame but this whole “_insert random qb_ would have won” shyt is ridiculous. Pats won so many games by playing good D and Tom capitalizing on mistakes. When that didn’t happen, Tom lost. Ask the Eagles about that.

I’m certain GB makes a comeback if their D was able to stop the 9ers. Something the Pats D did against the Falcons in the Super Bowl.

 

[Lootpack]

@Asantehene You cool peoples, but comparing him to Phillip Rivers tho?

 

[Dallas' 4 Eva]

He always plays terrible in the championship game. Blame the defense all you want, coming into yesterdays game(and after yesterdays game still) Rodgers had more turnovers than touchdowns in NFC Championship games. The only thing that has remained the same now through all their playoff short comings now is Rodgers. Proof is in the pudding bruh.

 

[FabTrey]

How many games has Brady won when his D gave up 40 points in the playoffs. I’ll help. ZERO. And before you talk about picks, Brady has won several playoff games while turning the ball over a lot.

Again, Rodgers deserves his fair share of the blame but this whole “_insert random qb_ would have won” shyt is ridiculous. Pats won so many games by playing good D and Tom capitalizing on mistakes. When that didn’t happen, Tom lost. Ask the Eagles about that.

I’m certain GB makes a comeback if their D was able to stop the 9ers. Something the Pats D did against the Falcons in the Super Bowl.

aint nobody gonna shyt on rodgers if he played like brady did against the eagles breh. just face it. rodgers don't play up to his standards when it matters the most. just a tremendous talent, but not the GOAT tier QB like brady or montana. it's been a decade. top 10 QB, but not the GOAT tier.

 

[BlueHeffner]

Have ya'll watched Packers games this year?

Who is he supposed to throw to besides #17? Can you even name the motherfukkers we got at WR? Have you seen Jimmy Graham this season?

Rodgers played pretty good this season.

Also, let's go through the playoff losses

2011: Packers were 15-1 and lost to Giants. Rodgers was terrible in that game turning it over and the Packers defense couldn't stop the Giants.
2012: Packers were 12-4, beat Joe Webb Vikings in Wild Card. Lost to the 49ers in the Divisional with Kapernick running all over the defense.
2013: Packers were 9-6-1. Rodgers broke his collarbone, came back at the end of the year to the beat the Bears, win the division. Lost to the 49ers in the Wild Card in a back and forth game. 49ers had the ball last, kicked a FG to win
2014: Packers were 12-4. Rodgers was amazing against the Cowboys. Then lead Packers to a 16-0 lead against Seahawks (but left TDs on the field). Packers had a 19-7 lead with under 5 minutes left. Offense stagnated. Special Teams choked. Defense couldn't get one more stop. Was this all on Rodgers?
2015: Packers were 10-6. Beat the Redskins in DC in the Wild Card. Go to Arizona, make a wild come back. Go to to Overtime, defense gives up the game winning TD. Rodgers doesn't get the ball back.
2016: Packers were 10-6. Got into the postseason a 6 game winning streak. Beat the Giants who went partying on a boat during the week in the Wild Card. Beat the Cowboys in Divisional Round. Get blown the fukk out by Atlanta.
2017: No Playoffs
2018: No Playoffs
2019: Packers are 13-3. Beat Seahawks in the Divisional Round. Rodgers had an INT in the first half which was terrible. Also nearly fumbled earlier in the game which led to a bad punt. Also had a snap that he didn't get which gave 49ers another posession. The offense was bad. Defense couldn't stop Mostert or the Niners rushing attack ala the Kapernick game.

Rodgers has his share in the blame but for some of these games, even if he was perfect, the Packers weren't winning them. If he was perfect today, they still lose. If he was perfect in Atlanta, they still fukking lose. Against Arizona, they still lose.

Breh dont do this shyt


There are countless QBs in the past that have been clowned for the same thing

 

[Formerly known as...]

Rodgers is dope but he is and never was GOAT. He will never be in that discussion. Is he considered the GOAT QB at Green Bay amongst their fans?