At this point it is what it is, Aaron Rodgers is nowhere near the GOAT discussion

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,067
Reputation
6,479
Daps
173,906
He ain’t even better than Brees. But he and Brees will both be in that tier of never being as revered as Peyton and Tom at this point until either one can get their team back to a Super Bowl while actually contributing mightily.

Rodgers still top 10 though. It’s the media who got enamored with him and crowned him as a GOAT candidate before he even got to a second Super Bowl no less.

Mahomes the new shiny toy for the media. If he wins in two weeks, he’ll be the undisputed newly anointed “future GOAT” by the media. From there, it’ll be up to Pat to play up to the crazy expectations and win another super bowl.
Looking at Brees’ playoff record, this thread should be about him. :patrice:
 

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,067
Reputation
6,479
Daps
173,906

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
43,851
Reputation
-387
Daps
91,416
For the people who shyt on Aarom to dyckeat tom consider this

Tom Brady has won 6 playoff games in which he was thrown 2 or more INTs in the game (not including fumbles) including winning 2 playoff games in which we he thrown 3 INTs in said game.

Up until last night rodgers had 1 games in his career in which he thrown 2 INTs and he is now 1-2. Tom brady is 6-4 in those same kind of games
 

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,067
Reputation
6,479
Daps
173,906
I know he is better skill wise but do the fans rate him higher than Favre? I know thye loved Favre, I am just asking the question.

Who do they consider their GOAT QB?
If fans don’t, then they aren’t thinking deeply.

Rodgers is better than Favre.

Favre had a long stretch in his career where he was holding the Packers hostage because of his play. He was younger than Rodgers currently is too.
 

Bboystyle

FIRE MATT LAFLEUR
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
48,001
Reputation
5,942
Daps
80,965
Reppin
So. Cal
yes the same Manning has been to 4 different Super Bowls, with 4 different coach staffs, 4 different WR corps, 4 different running back groups, 4 different defenses and won 2. Peyton is like 2nd in every playoff stat. Rodgers is a career loser at this point.


U really giving credit to his 2nd ring? :mjlol:

The guy was worse then Tim Tebow that run. One of the most pathetic display of QB play i have ever saw next to Joe Webb. Goes to show u idiots that QB play does not effect wins.

Manning is a playoff choker and loser but his defense carried him. Congrats
 
Last edited:

Stone

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
15,437
Reputation
746
Daps
31,083
Reppin
NULL
U really giving credit to his 2nd ring? :mjlol:

The guy was worse then Tim Tebow that run. One of the most pathetic display of QB play i have ever saw next to Joe Webb. Goes to show u idiots that QB play does not effect wins.

Manning is a playoff choker and loser but his defense carried him. Congrats
Eh, Peyton’s played winning football in the playoffs more often than not. Don’t let the rough start fool you. Stats don’t tell the whole story either especially just the regular counting stats

he’s also sustained a high level of play at QB for like twice as long as Rodgers has. Not the same
 

Bboystyle

FIRE MATT LAFLEUR
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
48,001
Reputation
5,942
Daps
80,965
Reppin
So. Cal
Eh, Peyton’s played winning football in the playoffs more often than not. Don’t let the rough start fool you. Stats don’t tell the whole story either especially just the regular counting stats

he’s also sustained a high level of play at QB for like twice as long as Rodgers has. Not the same


Winning playoff football? He has a damn losing record before his defense carried his sorry ass to his 2nd ring :dead:


Id sure hope he would have sustain a high level of play since he played 17 years vs rodgers 12. Rodgers has been playing at a high level 8 of his 12 years. 2 of them he was injured
 

Stone

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
15,437
Reputation
746
Daps
31,083
Reppin
NULL
Winning playoff football? He has a damn losing record before his defense carried his sorry ass to his 2nd ring :dead:


Id sure hope he would have sustain a high level of play since he played 17 years vs rodgers 12. Rodgers has been playing at a high level 8 of his 12 years. 2 of them he was injured
2009-2014 Rodgers was great. Hasn’t been great since
 
Top