At this point it is what it is, Aaron Rodgers is nowhere near the GOAT discussion
- Thread starter Ohene
- Start date
There has always been tiers
You do know seattle gets paid 2 play ad well. They just not gonna let aaron march up and down the field as defending super bowl champs
I AM WARHOL
Veteran
nikka are you serious?? Do I have to explain the nature of sports to you? That's every game but when you are in the GOAT convo you're supposed to make things shake despite your opponent.
DetroitEWarren
Veteran
Ineedmoney504
SOHH ICEY...WE EATIN
Wait wait. @NYC Rebel and @Jplaya2023 i can pull up threads of y’all placing the full blame of getting blown out in bowls on elway but y’all caping for Rodgers 
the Broncos was getting blown out by better teams in the bowl.
On it difference is elway went to like 5 bowls by the time he was Rodgers age
Bum can’t even go to his 2nd.
Old Jonny boy>>>>
the Broncos was getting blown out by better teams in the bowl. On it difference is elway went to like 5 bowls by the time he was Rodgers age
Bum can’t even go to his 2nd. Old Jonny boy>>>>
Mrhateeverything
All Star
favre isn't in a goat discussion either.You all really believe the stupid shyt you all type. Rodgers doesn’t perform in big games yet Favre’s bad season ending interceptions.
Rivers and Eli are not in this discussion and we will leave it there.
Some of you are just dumber then a bag of rocks.
With both them its a pick your poison.
Both are great QBs but I prefer the gunslinger who goes out swinging than the ultra careful guy who protects his stats and doesn't take risk . Both cost your team in different ways
I'ma take favre all day over Rodgers .
People forget favre was the top dog for years in a tougher league .
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
Funny...I mention Elway season numbers:Wait wait. @NYC Rebel and @Jplaya2023 i can pull up threads of y’all placing the full blame of getting blown out in bowls on elway but y’all caping for Rodgers
On it difference is elway went to like 5 bowls by the time he was Rodgers age
Old Jonny boy>>>>
- 1 more INT than TD for his career at year ten
- Never in the league as Montana and Marino
- Carried by The TD bail out
- Defense never got credit for going to those Super Bowls
I've always said the real Super Bowls were the NFC Championship games. Never did I blame elway for losing a single super bowl. they were the lesser team.
That's a lie.
Don't be a dog shyt poster
Last edited:
Please find where i said its all elway. Those denver teams were underdogs with the exception i think against the skinsWait wait. @NYC Rebel and @Jplaya2023 i can pull up threads of y’all placing the full blame of getting blown out in bowls on elway but y’all caping for Rodgers
On it difference is elway went to like 5 bowls by the time he was Rodgers age
Old Jonny boy>>>>
Dallas' 4 Eva
Superstar
Aaron Rodgers isn't trash I wouldn't say that cause I'd still put him in my top 10, but all this GOAT talk needs to cease unless he has a bunch of late career success that he was a key factor for.
NYC Rebel
...on the otherside of the pond
Exactly. I don't recall either of us saying "they lost the Super Bowl because of him."
Dude is full of shyt.
that's why stats do lie. brady threw 2 INTs against the seahawks. you gonna fault brady for that? how about against the chiefs last year?
those 2 games alone trumps anything rodgers have done in the playoffs.
on top of that 07 san diego ugly win was a classic brady where he was struggling all game long, but just finds the way to win a game.
let's face it. Rodgers had probably 3 shining moments in the playoffs. good for 1 episode on 30 for 30. brady? it would have to be a minimum 6 episode special
that's why stats do lie. brady threw 2 INTs against the seahawks. you gonna fault brady for that? how about against the chiefs last year?
those 2 games alone trumps anything rodgers have done in the playoffs.
on top of that 07 san diego ugly win was a classic brady where he was struggling all game long, but just finds the way to win a game.
let's face it. Rodgers had probably 3 shining moments in the playoffs. good for 1 episode on 30 for 30. brady? it would have to be a minimum 6 episode special
Yes classic brady indeed being bailed out by his defense despite his turnover prone ways. Rogers has 2 be damn near perfect and sometimes thats not even enough
yseJ
Empire strikes back
while you have some point, fact is most elite or even hof qbs tend to have that game once in a while
do people remember peyton and the colts losing to the jets 0 to 41 in the playoffs ?
we're talking about offense featuring peyton manning, reggie wayne, marvin harrison and edgerrin james not scoring a single point against a defense which was decent, but not really touching this niner squad. their best player was prolly john abraham and they were a middle of the pack defense, if not worse in the regular season and had a 9-7 record.