Baker Mayfield or Justin Herbert?

[JesusFOREVER]

Need to see Herbert outside of Greg Roman’s offense

 

[the next guy]

so its herbert

 

[KidJSoul]

No, he’s on a team with a bunch of weapons with a greenlight to throw the ball. No one was entertaining this shyt when Herbert had Keenan and Mike Williams. Jameis threw for 5000 with those guys. Baker isn’t doing shyt with the Chargers weapons. But I’m going to have fun bumping this thread this year. Baker isn’t him.

 

[No1]

Need to see Herbert outside of Greg Roman’s offense

I hate that Harbaugh loves this guy.

 

[BrehWyatt]

I'm sure there are plenty of things Herbert can work on. I don't doubt that. I'd like to see him be better in the playoffs, too.

But his effort against the Texans deserves as much credit as one can give somebody in a loss.

 

[the next guy]

Baker is just a better player than Herbert right now, period.

feels like this is still true

 

[MyApps]

Just a reminder

Lamar Jackson won an MVP in a Greg Roman offense with fewer weapons than Herbert.

If Herpert is that guy, he gets it done. MVP or SOME playoff success.

He's outside the Top 10.