better catalog: Nas or Kanye West? (Poll)

[mikishere]

Nas 9/10 or higher albums: Illmatic, Stillmatic, It Was Written
Kanye 9/10 or higher albums: College Dropout, Late Registration, Graduation, MBDTF

Nas 4/10 or lower albums: HHID, Nastradamus, Streets Disciple
Kanye 4/10 or lower albums: Yeezus?

i'll take kanye

 

[The Ruler 09]

Who cares? Do they act like women when someone questions their music or for this instance put them side by side to another artist and compare them?

If it's that ridiculous y'all would just skip over the thread.

Yes, Kanye fans often act like the biggest bytches lol. Someonne negged me cause I didn't like Yeezus lmao. It is very ridiculous, I do ignore most Kanye threads but this 1 has a legendary Hip Hop artist in Nas in the title so checked this 1 out.

 

[mobbinfms]

Nas 9/10 or higher albums: Illmatic, Stillmatic, It Was Written
Kanye 9/10 or higher albums: College Dropout, Late Registration, Graduation, MBDTF

Nas 4/10 or lower albums: HHID, Nastradamus, Streets Disciple
Kanye 4/10 or lower albums: Yeezus?

i'll take kanye

Graduation is nowhere near a 9.
None of those Nas albums (with the exception of Nastradamus) is a 4 or lower.

To me - when Nas is great - he's a 10.
When Kanye is great - he's 8/9.
That's all that matters really - and why its easily Nas.

 

[head shots101]

kanye is a better rapper and better artist

better rapper? lol nikka don't even write his own shyt......yo I think i'm done posting in the booth...

 

[ROFL_GUY]

luh these threads


cacs cant help but expose themselves

 

[Foxmulder]

MBDTF was horrible too overall. Hollow. Maybe 2 mics?. 5 out of 10.

C'mon breh you going too far.

1.nas
1a.kanye

They both GOAT's

 

[The Ruler 09]

I actually liked MBDTF - lyrically I thought he stepped it up a notch and the production was nice on most of the songs. ALbum flows really well too.

I thought it was garbage, non of these songs are listenable to me.....

9."Runaway" (featuring Pusha T)

• West
• Emile Haynie
• Thornton
• Bhasker
• Dean
• Jones
• John Branch

• West
• Emile
  [*]Bhasker
  [*]Dean

9:0810."Hell of a Life"

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Mike Caren
  • Wilson
  • Dean
  • Sylvester Stewart
  • Tony Joe White
  • Terence Butler
  • Anthony Iommi
  • John Osbourne
  • William Ward

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Caren
    [*]No I.D.
    [*]Dean

5:2711."Blame Game" (featuring John Legend)

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Justin Franks
  • Khloe Mitchell
  • Dean
  • John Stephens
  • Richard James

• 
  
  
  • West
  • DJ Frank E
  • Dean[a]

7:4912."Lost in the World" (featuring Bon Iver)

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Bhasker
  • Manu Dibango
  • James Brown
  • Vernon
  • Gil Scott-Heron

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Bhasker

4:1613."Who Will Survive in America"

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Bhasker
  • Scott-Heron

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Bhasker

1:38
5."All of the Lights"

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Bhasker
  • Jones
  • Warren Trotter

• 
  
  
  • West
  • Bhasker

4:59

 

[NvrCMyNut]

Disproportionate to what? Published statistics on Nas fans??

Reality.

 

[mobbinfms]

Reality.

Your reality or my reality?

 

[The Ruler 09]

The only song I ever really have a desire to listen to again from that album is Devil In A Dress, and even then prefer the non album solo version much more.

 

[The Ruler 09]

Graduation is nowhere near a 9.
None of those Nas albums (with the exception of Nastradamus) is a 4 or lower.

To me - when Nas is great - he's a 10.
When Kanye is great - he's 8/9.
That's all that matters really - and why its easily Nas.

Nastradamus is much higher than a 4.

 

[mobbinfms]

Nastradamus is much higher than a 4.

I can see that - but that was the third strike against him at the time. The Firm album was awful, I Am was disappointing (although the bootleg was ) and then Nastradamus was simply abysmal.
As a heavy Nas fan at the time, it seemed like the nail in the coffin.

Just looking at it objectively - its probably better than a 4.

 

[NoHalfWay]

no you idiot naS stans just have no reading comprehension and think "naS doesn't need a ghostwriter" means "i didn't feed bars to naS"

Cite your source first. I don't remember all this shyt

According to what you posted he said like half a line and wrote the book. Ok?

I'm sure Ron Isely wrote the hook on Project Windows. It's the fukking hook

You Dream Hampton fukk boys took that "Jay E and Stic wrote the majority of Untitled" and ran with it. After Stic & Jay said they had bare minimum involvement with the lyrics (the verses, the shyt that matters when it come to Nas) and they did production.

fukk outta here Talkin bout "Jay E's style is written all on Queens Get The Money"

Jay E's style? JAY ELECTRONICA'S STYLE? Jay Electronica, the guy with the style that has been majorly influenced by NAS' STYLE?

Go to sleep nikka

 

[Bickin Back Being Bool]

untitled had ghostwriters, word to jay electronica and dead prez

 

[eerieBell]

How the fukk does one rapper maintain a strong mainstream career for over 20 years by only putting out one good album?

Do y'all read the shyt y'all type?

I swear to God Nas must be some sort of magician if his whole career survived this long off the strength of an album put out in 1994

I've never heard of no shyt like that

wu tang did