Broussard lists his Top 20 NBA GOATs w/Tiers

[cartierhoe]

I’m honestly not sure what definitively puts Magic a tier above Bird besides passing. And Bird was an underrated passer himself, if anything they need to be on the same tier.

 

[Buckeye Fever]

I don't care about rankings.

But I think an interesting discussion could be had over what people think separates Giannis from David Robinson.

I'd pick the Admiral over Giannis. That's just me, though.

 

[knickscrusaderm]

Man stfu. You moving the goal post by appealing to emotion fallacy. Chris Bosh made many all stars and he was in Toronto. I can name you a bunch of similae cases. I am stating facts. If you a great player on a bad team, you're making the all stars. so you miss me with your bs.

nikka Bosh made those all star teams in the “Leastern” conference as Kobe stans have called it. You think he gets the same consideration in the West losing as much as he did?

No Kobe is not tier 1

 

[Mike18jj]

We can go off a combination of them all. You think KG was a better basketball player than Giannis?

Giannis hasn't had any teams as great as the '08 Celtics, but most of his teams were better than most of Garnett's Minnesota teams...

KG was an better all-round player then Giannis to me, KG had a way better jumpshot/Post game, and better defender. You can even say If Kg played today he would be the definition of a unicorn, I wish KG would've left sooner though.

Giannis is a more dominate player then KG and definitely takes advantage of this era not to dimmish him though.

Not mad if people have Giannis over though, I just think it's closer.

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

I'd pick the Admiral over Giannis. That's just me, though.

I would too

 

["It Was Always Jerry"]

Kobe is a top ten player on nearly all list except here. Go figure

 

[qnsfinest]

No specific order

Tier 1- Jordan, LeBron and Kareem. Ya gotta stop disrespecting kareem by leaving him off

Tier 2- Magic, Bird, Duncan, Shaq, hakeem

Tier 3- kobe, steph, giannis (hate his game, but can’t deny is accolades), kd, malone, joker

Tier 4- barkley, kg, dirk, admiral

Not ranking players i didn’t see play, so no russell or wilt or oscar

 

[FukkaPaidEmail]

I’m swapping Wade and KD.

Wade proved that he can be the man to lead a squad to a ring . KD has the better overall skill set but he’s obviously missing something intangible that made him have to go to GSW and form the avengers to actually win


And at this point I’m not sure what’s keeping Wilt a tier above Hakeem and Jokic

 

[High quality poster]

Dirk too low and Kobe isn't top 10

Your mom shoulda drank you

 

[Dwight Howard]

KD not better than Dirk, Giannis or Jokic idc

Dirk has ZERO case over KD

 

[FukkaPaidEmail]

Dirk has ZERO case over KD

..You can say KD is better but Dirk having ZERO case is insane .

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Kareem should be tier 1A or 2

 

[Apprentice]

..You can say KD is better but Dirk having ZERO case is insane .

Won’t even reply to some dumb shyt like that

KD joining a champion in free agency ain’t making him better than someone who earned they shyt

 

[NZA]

i dont believe in 1A. that is tier 2.

 

[DonRe]

Id put kd over larry.

KD is a top 4 offensive player of all time. Larry couldnt dribble out of shoe box.

Jokic may have the stats but doesnt have the chips to be where he is. Giannis either.