You're actually giving me something to debate here. I am pretty sure though that you know that it's not just Ye stans who believe that he's a great producer unless you think the vast majority of people who have discussed his production and albums to be Ye stans. I can see what you don't like about his production and note it as valid criticism, and I can cosign that all of those producers you named are better than him. Past that, I still disagree. I don't feel that Be is monotonous as I keep coming back to it every year or so and feel the same way I did when I first heard it.
The vast majority of people placing Ye's production and his albums on a pedestal are stans and casuals, tho. Cac bloggers. That's the whole point

what's the difference between this?
and these:
Heads don't fukk with Ye nearly as much as his stans think.