Dead ball or TD? Controversial return helps Memphis beat Mississippi State. EDIT: SEC admits error

What's the right call?

  • Dead ball

    Votes: 16 64.0%
  • Touchdown

    Votes: 9 36.0%

  • Total voters
    25

Silky Johnson

The Master Investbreh
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
1,906
Reputation
290
Daps
5,418
Reppin
Hatersbridge, BX
Touching the ball doesn't down a punt and the first touch rule was in play. #1 and #33 needed to gain possession to stop the play.

The back judge assumed these dumb asses weren't going to leave the ball on the ground and that's where he fukked up.

Also, waving hands don't mean shyt. You play to the whistle. If he blows his whistle, the play is over regardless of his hand swag.

That's a touchdown
 

We Ready

The Malarkey Cutter
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
15,668
Reputation
6,036
Daps
32,214
Reppin
Indiana
Touching the ball doesn't down a punt and the first touch rule was in play. #1 and #33 needed to gain possession to stop the play.

The back judge assumed these dumb asses weren't going to leave the ball on the ground and that's where he fukked up.

Also, waving hands don't mean shyt. You play to the whistle. If he blows his whistle, the play is over regardless of his hand swag.

That's a touchdown




Yeah, ok. Even thought they admitted it shouldn't have been.
 

staticshock

Veteran
Joined
Apr 15, 2017
Messages
39,797
Reputation
5,847
Daps
168,461
Reppin
Atlanta
Touching the ball doesn't down a punt and the first touch rule was in play. #1 and #33 needed to gain possession to stop the play.

The back judge assumed these dumb asses weren't going to leave the ball on the ground and that's where he fukked up.

Also, waving hands don't mean shyt. You play to the whistle. If he blows his whistle, the play is over regardless of his hand swag.

That's a touchdown

The play was dead..MSU touched it, ending the play.
 
Top