Detroit Lions and Matthew Stafford agree to part ways

PortCityProphet

Follow me to the truth
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
80,692
Reputation
17,595
Daps
274,853
Reppin
Bama ass DC
He's a 2-3 year player before he completely falls off and enters old white stuck in the past QB territory.
And didn't he fukk up his back this year too?
Anything more than a 3rd is too much.

Dude ain't a superbowl winning qb material that'll put a team over the hump. He'd have to be carried there like a Jimmy G
 

xXMASHERXx

Superstar
Joined
May 15, 2012
Messages
9,922
Reputation
1,740
Daps
36,562
For some reason people think he’s the reason for the lions failures and just overall choke artist/perennial loser

he’s not Mahomes or Rodgers but he’s not some trash either
He's not Wilson or Watson or Brady or Brees either. I would most people would have him either in the top 10 or just out. He might not be the reason for the Lion's failures but he didn't help at times.
 

iceberg_is_on_fire

Wearing Lions gear when it wasn't cool
Joined
Jun 11, 2012
Messages
23,683
Reputation
5,323
Daps
66,898
Reppin
Lombardi Trophies in Allen Park
He's not Wilson or Watson or Brady or Brees either. I would most people would have him either in the top 10 or just out. He might not be the reason for the Lion's failures but he didn't help at times.

As sure as I can possibly be, he will show that he's in the ballpark of Alex Smith next year. A lot of times, he wasn't a part of the larger problem but he was never part of the solution. Look at our drafting, we kept trying to give Stafford the world through the draft. That's the main reason the defensive side looks like hot ass trash.
 

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
56,088
Reputation
21,607
Daps
306,398
As sure as I can possibly be, he will show that he's in the ballpark of Alex Smith next year. A lot of times, he wasn't a part of the larger problem but he was never part of the solution. Look at our drafting, we kept trying to give Stafford the world through the draft. That's the main reason the defensive side looks like hot ass trash.

Nah Stafford is better than Smith. Smith is/was a game manager. Stafford can move the ball down field without effort, and make every throw. The problem is that the Lions are a historically terrible organization. We talk about how the organization tried to give Stafford the world but at the same time...this dude spent a weirdly long portion of his career with bum ass receivers and no decent pass catching TEs. He was going out there with no run game, most years. Questionable o-line play for years. And of course a defense that was often terrible. Last couple years he had the weapons and o-line to win...but the defense was (literally) historically bad and our run game was questionable at best.

Now he's presumably going to go to a team that is truly built to win, with all the pieces MOST quarterbacks need to win. If he goes to Indy he'll have a great o-line, great run game, solid receivers, and a good defense. Same story to varying degrees in San Fran, Washington, Pittsburg, and Denver. I can definitely see a team making a run in the playoffs with him, and it's gonna confirm everything we've said for a decade about the Detroit organization and fan culture.

Stafford isn't a top 5 QB. But he's good enough to win with, and if he had fallen into the hands of even a competent organization in 2009, he'd have multiple playoff wins by now.
 

NormanConnors

Detroit/MSU Spartan Life
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
31,578
Reputation
6,150
Daps
65,170
Reppin
Detroit
He's a 2-3 year player before he completely falls off and enters old white stuck in the past QB territory.
And didn't he fukk up his back this year too?
Anything more than a 3rd is too much.

Dude ain't a superbowl winning qb material that'll put a team over the hump. He'd have to be carried there like a Jimmy G

His back is decimated. The inevitable is near, besides the fact he is a mediocre qb
 

Reggie

Veteran
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
91,766
Reputation
5,054
Daps
193,784
Reppin
Virginia
Stafford seems to be a perfect match for a team like the Redskins who have hired the GM who drafted him. But if he is serious about trying to win he should probably try and work something out with a team like the Colts or Steelers.
 

iceberg_is_on_fire

Wearing Lions gear when it wasn't cool
Joined
Jun 11, 2012
Messages
23,683
Reputation
5,323
Daps
66,898
Reppin
Lombardi Trophies in Allen Park
he's not trash, detroit is just a trash team that he's played well for. detroit has been a shyt organization for decades...

Passer Rating Rank by Season

2009: 29th
2010: Injury N/A
2011: 5th
2012: 22nd
2013: 19th
2014: 21st
2015: 9th
2016: 13th
2017: 6th
2018: 25th
2019: Injury N/A
2020: 14th

So, do you mean well, in spurts? Because, we know most of y'all aren't watching him play except with your team opposes us. His toughness and the comebacks (partly due to him shytting the bed in the first half of games) have created a narrative for him. One that is beneficial because of a lot of the ineptitude of the Lions. However, I just provided stats that are largely reflective of him. He's an average quarterback. Big arm, makes horrible decisions with spotty mechanics. He currently has more pick sixes than Russell Wilson, Aaron Rodgers and Alex Smith put together. Is that the defense's fault too? Reasons like that is why he publicly had the playbook reduced to a kindergarten level for him. I'm just glad the scapegoating will be gone next year. Sure, you can say #SOL for some of the things, you can directly point at #9 for others.
 
Top