Donell Jones or Tank

who has the better catalogue?

  • Donell Jones

    Votes: 80 89.9%
  • Tank

    Votes: 9 10.1%

  • Total voters
    89

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
Bushed
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
337,890
Reputation
-34,994
Daps
641,374
Reppin
The Deep State
Any person that questions Tank's vocals doesn't know anything about R&B. He's a true vocalist.

I don't think most of the people in here heard much of Tank outside a few songs.



Very very few people could do a better cover.

still lacks the musicality of Donell IMO.

I see Tank going straight to the vein of Trey Songz, but Tank is obviously better than Trey, but theres a certain flatness to Tank and you can't deny that.
 

Bmezy

All Star
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
1,499
Reputation
665
Daps
4,100
still lacks the musicality of Donell IMO.

I see Tank going straight to the vein of Trey Songz, but Tank is obviously better than Trey, but theres a certain flatness to Tank and you can't deny that.


Nahh bro. I admit that Donnell has bigger classics and his best songs are better than Tank’s, butTank’s catelog is underrated, imo. He’s also very versatile. He gives you sad morbid simp shyt of 90s, dirty bed sex jams of 00s and hip hop influenced phrasing and flow to amcompliment the high hats and 808s of 10s. His label/team just doesn’t market him well for some reason

How is Tank lacking musically breh when compared to Donnell? Tank is more musically talented. Just as a vocalist alone, he’s is still one of the greatest doing it.. huge range, development in every part of the voice .. You can tell a vocal musician by how they phrase and place their riffs. Homie ear is dangerous.. his pitch control to be able to change keys, run up and down the scale as effortlessly as he does. nahh bro.
You pulling shyt out your ass with the ‘flatness’ angle. Tank’s intonation is top tier.. His gospel background has trained him well..

Skill on the keys heavily underrated too.

 

☑︎#VoteDemocrat

The Original
Bushed
WOAT
Supporter
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
337,890
Reputation
-34,994
Daps
641,374
Reppin
The Deep State
Nahh bro. I admit that Donnell has bigger classics and his best songs are better than Tank’s, butTank’s catelog is underrated, imo. He’s also very versatile. He gives you sad morbid simp shyt of 90s, dirty bed sex jams of 00s and hip hop influenced phrasing and flow to amcompliment the high hats and 808s of 10s. His label/team just doesn’t market him well for some reason

How is Tank lacking musically breh when compared to Donnell? Tank is more musically talented. Just as a vocalist alone, he’s is still one of the greatest doing it.. huge range, development in every part of the voice .. You can tell a vocal musician by how they phrase and place their riffs. Homie ear is dangerous.. his pitch control to be able to change keys, run up and down the scale as effortlessly as he does. nahh bro.
You pulling shyt out your ass with the ‘flatness’ angle. Tank’s intonation is top tier.. His gospel background has trained him well..

Skill on the keys heavily underrated too.


Tank has managed to eek out an existence with his writing, but his range is very limited vocally.

This thread pitted these two against each other.

Those were the choices.

Now you're mad someone compared them.
 

Bmezy

All Star
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
1,499
Reputation
665
Daps
4,100
nikka said there’s a certain flatness in Tank that can’t be denied .. where breh.

Tank sings like an elite musician playing their sax or piano.
 

Bmezy

All Star
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
1,499
Reputation
665
Daps
4,100
Tank has managed to eek out an existence with his writing, but his range is very limited vocally.

This thread pitted these two against each other.

Those were the choices.

Now you're mad someone compared them.

Im not mad, bro.. I’m just trying to inform you alittle because you talking about music aspects that you clearly have limited understanding on.

First u gotta explain how Tank’s range is limited. then tell me when you’ve ever heard him go flat. You didn’t listen to that video, bubs.. homie sifted through 3 octaves in chest voice easily. How many nikkas in the industry showing control of that magnitude. You don’t know what you’re talking about and the criticism isn’t valid. I could see if you were to say that he never had clout and had a lackluster music career or that Donnel had more popular music, but this nikka musical skills vocally are one of the best.
 
Top