Dr. Dre is the greatest hip hop producer of all time. Hands down. Nothing overrated about him

Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
268,960
Reputation
65,735
Daps
587,853
I agree to an extent. He's very good at what he does but the no ghost producers is far from accurate. And a LOT of 2001 is Mel-Man.

Yes he polishes stuff up and produces them to their full potential but Dre's whole camp is full of people accepting submissions, stealing the work, adding to it and fukking over the people actually putting the initial work in. I'm a massive Dre fan but I can't deny what I've learned, it taints the legacy somewhat.

Dre as a mucical visionary and producer is a long gone concept. Unknowns are regularly submitting work which he doesn't always do a lot of work to but takes 100% of the credit (and money) for.

Ghost producer does not equal a co producer

Mel-Man is credited on 2001
 

Awesome Wells

The Bobby Womack of Crack
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
13,193
Reputation
9,089
Daps
43,661
Reppin
Uptown, NYC

BIG FACTS!!

Dre been the GOAT for 30+ years.

I just posted this in the other thread. Dude got beats from over 30 years ago that would kill sh*t right now.



People can have favorites and that's cool. But objectively, ain't nobody done what Dre's done behind the boards. EVER!

Top 3 for me is still Dre, Tip & Premier.
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
268,960
Reputation
65,735
Daps
587,853
BIG FACTS!!

Dre been the GOAT for 30+ years.

I just posted this in the other thread. Dude got beats from over 30 years ago that would kill sh*t right now.



People can have favorites and that's cool. But objectively, ain't nobody done what Dre's done behind the boards. EVER!

Top 3 for me is still Dre, Tip & Premier.



Gospel :salute:

Dre ain’t even my favorite producer, but I can’t deny the run and impact he’s had on hip hop
 

ADP

All Star
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,797
Reputation
1,426
Daps
7,081
Reppin
NULL
Other than strictly music he had a BIG hand in supporting some of the biggest rappers in history Snoop Em 50 Game if you add Nate, Cube and PAC and the fact that he had fantastic mic presence himself

No case can be made for anybody else, league of his own as far as im concerned

*From what is known, kind of a scum bag on a personal level, it is what it is...
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
268,960
Reputation
65,735
Daps
587,853
Exactly.

Q-Tip is my favorite. But I can't front on Dre. He's done this at a level most producers will never see.

Yessir

Exactly; Dre’s work for Ruthless alone puts him in another stratosphere.

Then you factor in his work on The Chronic and Doggystyle. This era is an era any producer wishes they had in terms of work and impact. Those 2 albums alone were a damn domino effect on hip hop

That’s like a lifetime achievement in producing in hip hop when things change and get old so quick


Then after all of that, he emerges once again in 99 with 2001
 

ADP

All Star
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,797
Reputation
1,426
Daps
7,081
Reppin
NULL
Yeah 2001 is an exception to the rule. I'm not going to go into a lot of detail over this but like I said I am a huge fan of Dre. But his 'productions' are not much more than mixing at this point.

What time period are you refering to ? After 2005 ? Or you think he ALWAYS was more of an engineer than a beat maker

Cause i couldnt name a top 10 beat of their own catalog from RZA or Preem after the same year

You can discuss less creative than others, not a personal favorite etc but his resume is unfukcwithable...

Everytime i hear that begining of California Love i only see goats for a couple seconds
 

Malcy86

All Star
Joined
Feb 2, 2017
Messages
1,447
Reputation
370
Daps
2,718
Reppin
Glasgow
What time period are you refering to ? After 2005 ? Or you think he ALWAYS was more of an engineer than a beat maker

Cause i couldnt name a top 10 beat of their own catalog from RZA or Preem after the same year

You can discuss less creative than others, not a personal favorite etc but his resume is unfukcwithable...

Everytime i hear that begining of California Love i only see goats for a couple seconds
Oh after 2005 absolutely. Like I said I'm not disputing his early work, but the past 20 years or so is questionable. Dre is phenomenal in his early years. Anyone who disputes that has no knowledge of music. His legacy can't be tarnished by later 'issues' and practices, he's still very good at what he does but the input isn't what it was. Not disputing his craft, talent or anything like that.

These days it's 99% his camp doing the work and Dre putting the final touches, and working his magic on it but there is a very, very toxic practice at work where his camp are stealing other peoples work, then Dre works on it. Dre potentially not at fault for that, I'm not going to say any more on it.
 

Malcy86

All Star
Joined
Feb 2, 2017
Messages
1,447
Reputation
370
Daps
2,718
Reppin
Glasgow
Tip is right up there if we’re talking across the board and how his influence even went into other genres, for example Neo Soul.
More so in recent years, His LL album was incredible. Pete Rock with Common, also incredible, then Dre's Missionary with Snoop was miles behind both of those albums.
 

Malcy86

All Star
Joined
Feb 2, 2017
Messages
1,447
Reputation
370
Daps
2,718
Reppin
Glasgow
It's a shame his WCRC work is often disregarded. I love that era too. I find it quite sad that it's regarded as camp or homosexual and not 'gangsta' by so many uneducated posters. Hip hop wasn't and ISN'T always gangsta, he was a huge part of pioneering the 80's West Coast sound along with so. so many others.
 

ADP

All Star
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,797
Reputation
1,426
Daps
7,081
Reppin
NULL
More so in recent years, His LL album was incredible. Pete Rock with Common, also incredible, then Dre's Missionary with Snoop was miles behind both of those albums.

Hes a "victim" of his own success in a way, so far removed from the real world and into corporate $$$ that even some of the beats sound like convoluted excel charts

Meanwhile Tip or Pete or Preemo maintained more of an artistic hip hop head aesthetic to what they do.
 

u mad son?

All Star
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
2,806
Reputation
873
Daps
8,976
Reppin
NULL
His fall off was weird though

Like usually you could attribute it to someone who stopped using samples, which is completely understandable.

But then he did 2001 which was mainly not samples and was absolute fukking fire.

I think once it came to stop using samples, he got rid of the people around him making it still sound fire, and he could never be the same producer as much as he wanted to.

Like yeah i get it, he will layer 2000 sounds on top of each other and make it sound clear but the shyt is wack and has no soul.

He kinda went the same route rza went
 
Top