Eli manning hall of fame

[Street Knowledge]

Would he be the first non all-pro player?

But then again he also played in the greatest QB era

There’s no era where eli is elite

 

[VegetasHairline]

Manning has had 'Hall of Fame moments, but not a Hall of Fame career'

Although denied this time, Manning maintains a good chance to get in.

www.espn.com

 

[Baka's Weird Case]

i just looked through the list of first ballot HOFers and if you seriously think eli manning is in that category of player you are an insane person

 

[Shadow King]

These fukk nikkas finna learn about not putting respeck on the name of Eli da gawd

Without Eli, Brady wouldve had 9. Just think about it. 9!!!

Eli is HOFer. You gotta look at who he won against. Dont care how mid he was. He had those 2 magical run.

fukk the NFL . They did my boy Eli dirty.

Eli is the definition of a Hall of Famer. He did historic shyt, that defined and made a big impact on the sport.

These bias sports analysts/writers are corny unathletic lames.

Hating ass lames won’t keep him out forever

 

[Shadow King]

He isnt a HOFer period


Same way Joe Flacco or Stafford wouldnt be one if they won another ring

This is debatable.

 

[Heelmatic]

Without Eli, Brady wouldve had 9. Just think about it. 9!!!

Eli is HOFer. You gotta look at who he won against. Dont care how mid he was. He had those 2 magical run.

fukk the NFL . They did my boy Eli dirty.

Eli is the definition of a Hall of Famer. He did historic shyt, that defined and made a big impact on the sport.

These bias sports analysts/writers are corny unathletic lames.

Y’all got a spot lined up for Nick Foles as well?

 

[PHamm]

Y’all got a spot lined up for Nick Foles as well?

Exactly

 

[Erratic415]

They’ll vote him in the same year as Brady gets in for fun.

 

[Erratic415]

Would he be the first non all-pro player?

But then again he also played in the greatest QB era

Among QBs, there’s John Elway, Warren Moon, Troy Aikman, and Roger Staubach.

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor

www.pro-football-reference.com

 

[Shadow King]

Y’all got a spot lined up for Nick Foles as well?

Eli is mid but leave it to the Coli to go too far.

 

[Harry B]

Among QBs, there’s John Elway, Warren Moon, Troy Aikman, and Roger Staubach.

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Pro Football QB Hall of Fame Monitor

www.pro-football-reference.com

I just said all-pro not all-pro first team.

I’m guessing all of them were second team? Perhaps, except Aikman. Elway even had that Josh Allen thing going, where he won MVP but wasn’t first team.

So Aikman is really more or less like Eli. He’s there due to team performance, not individual performances

 

[Harry B]

There’s no era where eli is elite

Go and look at 20s to 80s QBs stats

His worst like 23 TD 20 INT seasons look like MVP seasons back in the days

 

[Street Knowledge]

Go and look at 20s to 80s QBs stats

His worst like 23 TD 20 INT seasons look like MVP seasons back in the days

His rate stats are comparable to guys who played 40 years prior which is embarrassing. Like Dan Marino played a generation prior and his career passer rating is higher than eli.

Where is the evidence that Eli would be elite if you put him in a different era? Like if you put prime eli in todays nfl he’s lucky if he’s top 10.

There’s is no era where eli is considered elite.

 

[Harry B]

His rate stats are comparable to guys who played 40 years prior which is embarrassing. Like Dan Marino played a generation prior and his career passer rating is higher than eli.

Where is the evidence that Eli would be elite if you put him in a different era? Like if you put prime eli in todays nfl he’s lucky if he’s top 10.

Theirs is no era where eli is considered elite.

People were calling Marino, Montana and Fevre goats before Eli’s generation.



And I don’t know who said he was ever elite except you, but saying that he’s nothing cause the greatest passer of all times before his generation has slightly better career stats is not a good argument

 

[Street Knowledge]

People were calling Marino, Montana and Fevre goats before Eli’s generation.



And I don’t know who said he was ever elite except you, but saying that he’s nothing cause the greatest passer of all times before his generation has slightly better career stats is not a good argument

All those guys outclass Eli.

When mentioning all pros You originally said that Eli’s that he played in the “GOAT QB era”, the implication form that is somehow if you put him in another era he would be winning MVP’s, all pros, and generally stand out more.

Is that what you were implying?