Eli Manning is 116-116 currently
- Thread starter iceberg_is_on_fire
- Start date
filial_piety
Banned
i doubt he's going to HOF, looking deep into the numbers and his accolades and I don't see it. The D carried the team twice to the SB, elijah got the credit because the sbmvp is 90% of the time given to the QB.
I personally think they should have let him go sometime around 2013...watching him game to game is the weirdest thing ever...he still makes the same mistakes that he made in his first 3 seasons.
He seems like a nice kid though
I personally think they should have let him go sometime around 2013...watching him game to game is the weirdest thing ever...he still makes the same mistakes that he made in his first 3 seasons.
He seems like a nice kid though
Last edited:
He outplayed Brady the second time
Edit: And when a QB with a "playoff mode" can't win a playoff game outside of 2 magic runs he likely got carried by his defense.
Last edited:
Trojan 24
Veteran
The epitome of a very good QB
I'll give him props for making some huge plays in 2 playoff runs, even more props since they ended with Patriots losing both SBs, but he was never good enough to carry a bad team like his brother or other HOF caliber QBs often could
He'll probably make it though, he might not even be the worst Giants QB to make the HOF tbh
I'll give him props for making some huge plays in 2 playoff runs, even more props since they ended with Patriots losing both SBs, but he was never good enough to carry a bad team like his brother or other HOF caliber QBs often could
He'll probably make it though, he might not even be the worst Giants QB to make the HOF tbh
ISO
Pass me the rock nikka
The man has played behind the W.O.A.T. offensive lines
PIFF101
Bring back the Golden Era
Eli is a HOF, Now should he be benched for Jones already, I gave it to week 6 but these couple of games 
Let Eli gun that shyt out...dont change up now.
Can't stand the Giants but you gotta put more respect on their defense, especially their defensive line. Eli wasn't winning shootouts against the Pats...
You clearly have no idea how white privilege works.i doubt he's going to HOF, looking deep into the numbers and his accolades and I don't see it. The D carried the team twice to the SB, elijah got the credit because the sbmvp is 90% of the time given to the QB.
I personally think they should have let him go sometime around 2013...watching him game to game is the weirdest thing ever...he still makes the same mistakes that he made in his first 3 seasons.
He seems like a nice kid though
Thatrogueassdiaz
We're on the blood path now
People forget that Giants fans didn't want him to replace their starter when he got drafted--cant remember if it was Collins or not. just a few years into his career Giants fans wanted him and Coughlin out. People forget that shyt. They also forget that when he first went to New York a lot of the media said he couldnt/wouldn't acclimate to New York. Most of these criticisms also came from Archie being so involved.
Nowadays people act like he is untouchable, but at the beginning of his career everyone wanted him out
. Fans fickle as fukk.Edit: It was Kurt Warner. Warner mentored him, got traded to Arizona, and the rest is history. Collins was the starter the year before though.
I think eli actually looks serviceable...
He has no weapons..
And The secondary looks like ass...
That young boy behind him ain't ready to deal with this team.... they gonna be getting blown out like the dolphins...
Guarantee the Giants win week 3
He has no weapons..
And The secondary looks like ass...
That young boy behind him ain't ready to deal with this team.... they gonna be getting blown out like the dolphins...
Guarantee the Giants win week 3
UserNameless
Veteran
Beat Brady twice in the Bowl ... 
... when it comes to this football shyt, he forever good in my book .
... when it comes to this football shyt, he forever good in my book .
JMurder
SOHH Member since 01...
What about themEli is a HOF, Now should he be benched for Jones already, I gave it to week 6 but these couple of games
