Eli Manning is 116-116 currently

[Field Marshall Bradley]

GROWN MAN shyt against Bill Belichick defense





"To be the Man, you've got to beat the Man(ning)"

Man... I wanted Moss to get that ring... Eli gets respect for that win... but that was a team win.... not a hero win... you can easily say the giants front defensive 7 deserves the bulk of the credit

 

[get these nets]

Man... I wanted Moss to get that ring... Eli gets respect for that win... but that was a team win.... not a hero win... you can easily say the giants front defensive 7 deserves the bulk of the credit

this is a good post and I hear you, but QB get the money the spotlight and ALL the pressure/blame

and Eli marching down the field in clutch situations to score the go ahead touchdown against one of the best coaches in HISTORY and coming away with the W both times is GROWN MAN shyt.

If he chokes, the Giants lose.

Patriots/Beli/Brady are the BEST because they had a shot both times to win the game at the end.

 

[mson]

Maybe another run at the playoffs. Love of the game.

 

[JMurder]

Man... I wanted Moss to get that ring... Eli gets respect for that win... but that was a team win.... not a hero win... you can easily say the giants front defensive 7 deserves the bulk of the credit

At the end of the game... BOTH games...Eli had to score the game winning TD.

You guys need to stop discrediting Eli's importance in those Super Bowl victories.

 

[iceberg_is_on_fire]

For the nfl to put something out like this makes me think that many aren't sold on his hall of fame stature and maybe gauging the public's feelings on this.

My senses are rarely ever wrong.




With what Skip (Columnist) and Shannon (football player) said about him today, I bet there is a strong amount of people in both camps that feel that way.

 

[Trot LaRoc]

If namath is in....Eli will get in

 

[Bigblackted4]

Giants fans sound like abused lovers in this thread

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

Eli hasn't had a HOF caliber career but he has a HOF caliber narrative. We'll see which side wins out.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

At the end of the game... BOTH games...Eli had to score the game winning TD.

You guys need to stop discrediting Eli's importance in those Super Bowl victories.

NE averaged like 34 points a game that year.... Giants D held them to less than half of that

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Eli hasn't had a HOF caliber career but he has a HOF caliber narrative. We'll see which side wins out.

Yup... which is quite proper for current journalistic times

 

[K-Deini]

My goat

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

He's in. He beat the Pats twice.

 

[Knicksgarbageforever]

I can never hate on Eli. For 2 starts, he delivered better than anyone can ask. He is the sole reason why the Cheatriots dont have 8 rings. Why Tom Brady hasn't doubled Joe Montana on rings. God Bless him for that alone....

Tom can easily do that in 2 years especially with the moves the pats made recently

 

[jflores]

Plaxico shooting himself fukked Eli of a possibly third ring. That team was scary good and was in the process of two peating. Eli got Manningham, Steve Smith and Vic Cruz paid.

 

[Sadbrownsfan]

Eli has had one of the strangest careers I can remember

The forest gump of QBs.