Eli Manning is the 5th best QB
- Thread starter JAY?
- Start date
The War Report
NewNewYork
And first in Super Bowl rings.
JMurder
SOHH Member since 01...
close threadAnd first in Super Bowl rings.
And first in Super Bowl rings.
I just don't understand it
Obviously u a giants fan
Do u honestly think he's that good?
The War Report
NewNewYork
"When it's reppin time, I get on extra grind."-Elijah Manning.
HarlemsOwn
RIP Fresh
hardware speaks numbers
Do you honestly think Mike Vick is better?
Now?
No
I don't really think any1 I mentioned is better
But watching him play, I just can't see how he wins
He looks scared out there
I was just wondering if giants fans think he's actually good
Kinda like Yankees fans
If u tell them jeter has been a below average ss for the last 5 years
They tell u how manys rings he got
I could dig it
JMurder
SOHH Member since 01...
you obviously lied when you wrote "watching him play"
RhodyRum
Mark Gassed-A-Heaux
I'm a Jet fan. He's very, very good. He's the best 4th quarter QB in the league, and that's huge. When you say "he looks scared" you're mistaking that for his emotionless command of the O. Browning Nagle and Dave Brown looked scared. You're better with a level headed, calm QB who has ice water in his veins in crunch time over a jumpy, high/low extreme QB any day. My only criticism is he (and the team in general) play too much Kardiac Kid style football, especially last season, which is why their recent seasons are either a BIG HIT or just bust.
Im also a jets fan but I think
Brady
Peyton
Brees
Burger
Rodgers
Are clearly better
I think he's top 10 considering what he's done
But there's like 10 guys I'd pick before him easily
Brady plays emotionless
He's the ice water type
I don't see that in Eli tho
JMurder
SOHH Member since 01...
if that were true "he looks scared out there" would be the last statement you would make in regards to Eli breh
RhodyRum
Mark Gassed-A-Heaux
Compare his body language to his brother's in crunch time. You'll see the difference instantly. Peyton gets very jittery when the walls are closing in on the game and it's in his hands. Eli doesn't.