Eminem vs Jay, who has the higher highs, and who got the lower lows?

[Cloud McFly]

Jay-Z - Higher Highs
Eminem - Lower Lows

Pretty much everything after 8 Mile has been trash. I messed with a couple tracks on Relapse, but other than that, it’s been one and done for me.

 

[Yehuda]

WE MAKE SURE WE DROWN IN CHAMPAGNE, WASHING AWAY OUR SORROW
CAUSE WE DON'T WANNA FEEL THE DAMN PAIN, I HOPE I'M HUNGOVER TOMORROW

 

[Mr 18]

Eminem doesn't have a Reasonable Doubt and Jay doesn't have an Encore

Jay got KC doe

 

[Playaz Eyez]

Jay got KC doe

KC is Stillmatic compared to Encore

 

[SunZoo]

Jay got KC doe

KC is low key dope.

Encore got more heat than MCHG lol

That's the most nothing ass album ever and I still liked a couple joints, but it's probably the least impactful thing Jay has done.

 

[Rell84shots]

Kingdom Come was your first thought of a terrible album??? MCHG is Jay at his absolute worst. All of Eminem's albums have aged terribly, whereas Jay doesn't have that same problem.