Grade Peyton Mannings Bronco career

[Rigby.]

B

 

[ghostwriterx]

Not really. He had 2 special teams touchdowns to even get him that 7 point lead right before the Rocky Mountain Rainbow. If we're being honest, ST touchdowns rarely happen once in a game let alone twice, so you can easily make the argument that the ravens should've won that game 28-21. The hail mary was pretty much the universe doing its part to re-balance the extreme luck of TWO special teams touchdowns returned by Trindon Holliday in the same game.

Peyton also threw a pick 6 in that game, for good measure. And then the game ending interception in double OT. I don't see how that loss isn't on him.

He threw the go ahead td with 7 minutes left before Raheem Moore made the worst defensive mistake by a db I've ever seen to gift wrap the tie to Baltimore

Peyton didn't play particularly well in the two 2013 AFC playoff games leading up to the super bowl, and he's been abysmal all year this year. So in the end, all that is left is an impressive 35 game stretch of regular season games (from Week 5 in 2012 to Week 9 in 2014)

4tds 1pick 600+ yards, 72% completion percentage... yeah, he "didn't play particularly well"

 

[Jplaya2023]

He certainly won't do it alone with his arm but he's capable of making plays. He should've had 4 TDs against New England (overthrew Sanders and a WR dropped a TD)

no sanders stopped on the route, and peyton missed the receiver in the endzone threw it to far in front of him

 

[Jplaya2023]

Some of you are so blinded by hate. I would take those 4 playoff appearances and two Super bowls here in Buffalo any day.

buffalo had 4 straight sb appearances.

what did you rate them?

 

[Womb Raider]

How is anyone supposed to know otherwise? All I see is "Reppin: City of Brotherly Love"


You must not be too bright if you really don't know what an inference is.

You make an ass out of yourself when you assume things.

 

[TheEgyptianConniption]

buffalo had 4 straight sb appearances.

what did you rate them?

I was like 5 when that run started but everyone was a lot more excited about the Bills then they are now from what I remember.

 

[Cyber]

A, he's been great for Denver. Rahim Moore does his job and Peyton didn't break down in 2014 and all of a sudden he might be playing for his 3rd superbowl win (and 4th appearance) in 4 years, doesn't take away his dominance these past couple of years for the Broncos.

 

[Mandizi]

A-

 

[JameisNewton]

He threw the go ahead td with 7 minutes left before Raheem Moore made the worst defensive mistake by a db I've ever seen to gift wrap the tie to Baltimore

7 minutes? lol...that's an eternity in the NFL. Enough time for 3-4 more possessions even in the first and third quarters(i.e., not the end of a half) of a football game.


And again, take away 2 special returns TDs (which are of anomalous nature to begin with) and he's not even tying the game with that TD. And Raheem Moore's defensive miscue has nothing to do with the QB throwing the game sealing interception (on a terrible throw) in OT.

 

[JameisNewton]

A, he's been great for Denver. Rahim Moore does his job and Peyton didn't break down in 2014 and all of a sudden he might be playing for his 3rd superbowl win (and 4th appearance) in 4 years, doesn't take away his dominance these past couple of years for the Broncos.

if this and if that. Ok, 2 can play that "what if" game. If the Broncos beat the colts last year, they don't win in Foxboro. If the Patriots hadn't attempted an onside kick up 14-0 in the Eagles game, Peyton has to go to Foxboro again this year (and lose of course)

 

[all3rd]

B in regular season and D in playoffs so a C is the final score.

 

[Ineedmoney504]

7 minutes? lol...that's an eternity in the NFL. Enough time for 3-4 more possessions even in the first and third quarters(i.e., not the end of a half) of a football game.


And again, take away 2 special returns TDs (which are of anomalous nature to begin with) and he's not even tying the game with that TD. And Raheem Moore's defensive miscue has nothing to do with the QB throwing the game sealing interception (on a terrible throw) in OT.

it wasnt 7 minutes. it was less than 1 minute. cause once we got the ball back after that possession we just kneed and went into OT

edit: 43 seconds left on the clock

 

[KOBE]

When I voted on this poll there was 7 votes for A and 40+ for B. happened

 

[Juggalo Fred]

B in regular season and D in playoffs so a C is the final score.

B in regular season? ????

 

[Jesus]

C in playoffs is all matters...