torcher
Superstar
You cant give him an A becuz no matter what he's a underachiever but he has had a great career so it has to be a B or B-
Grade Peyton Mannings Bronco career
- Thread starter bl2k8
- Start date
MrFantastic
Pro
Has to be C+
Had the best wr core he ever played with.Best D he ever played with.
A for regular season performance.
D for post season play.
Anything else is being overly generous
Had the best wr core he ever played with.Best D he ever played with.
A for regular season performance.
D for post season play.
Anything else is being overly generous
Whatever grade you gave him with the colts should be the same you gave em with Broncos,he pretty much did the same thing...went to the playoffs/superbowl but you knew he probably had no chance of actually winning
He won a SB with the Colts and was productive there over a much longer stretch. fukk are you even talking about.
B+
Lakers Offseason
Superstar
Peyton went 1 and done twice with a great players around him.
Tebow with lesser players at least didn't go one and done
Tebow with lesser players at least didn't go one and done
WaddupDoe!
Steez.
A+ at choking
C- imo. two choke jobs & a fukking beat down in the super bowl while choking.
C- imo. two choke jobs & a fukking beat down in the super bowl while choking.
holidayinn21
:SmugMoneyMike:
C-
year 1 misplayed a hail mary. then the inevitable peyton pick
year 2. historic offense. dominated in an all-time worst SB performance.
year 3. dominated at home.
replace peyton's name with romo and nikkas would've been saying he's a choke artist.
year 1 misplayed a hail mary. then the inevitable peyton pick
year 2. historic offense. dominated in an all-time worst SB performance.
year 3. dominated at home.
replace peyton's name with romo and nikkas would've been saying he's a choke artist.
3 legit division titles, a SB trip, 12 wins a year, greatest offense ever, all in his late 30's coming off career threatening neck surgery. Anything less than a B is pure hate . How many QBs have had a better stretch since 12? It's about time to hang it up though, he looked absolutely pitiful today and unlike in other instances it wasn't just an isolated, situational thing. He's looked shaky the entire second half of the season. That paperwork is in review as we speak.
. How many QBs have had a better stretch since 12? It's about time to hang it up though, he looked absolutely pitiful today and unlike in other instances it wasn't just an isolated, situational thing. He's looked shaky the entire second half of the season. That paperwork is in review as we speak.THE MACHINE
night owl
C
Choke jobs. They were a playoff team when he got there. He choked year one (C-)...got exposed year 2 in the bowl (gets a B+ for making it)....choked at home against his heir in year three (C-).
Choke jobs. They were a playoff team when he got there. He choked year one (C-)...got exposed year 2 in the bowl (gets a B+ for making it)....choked at home against his heir in year three (C-).
havoc
Superstar
The Colts aren't wack, breh. They lit up many great defensive teams in the regular season. They ain't no joke with their high octane offense.
Brady3 legit division titles, a SB trip, 12 wins a year, greatest offense ever, all in his late 30's coming off career threatening neck surgery. Anything less than a B is pure hate
B-
Peyton went 1 and done twice with a great players around him.
Tebow with lesser players at least didn't go one and done
Tebow had to play in the wildcard round, which Manning never did as a Bronco.
So because Tebow "won" a wildcard game, he's better than Manning who was good enough to help ensure they never had to play in a wildcard game?
If the Broncos had been the #4 seed and beat the Bengals to you...that would have been more impressive?
What about him?