Grade Peyton Mannings Bronco career

[Still Benefited]

He won a SB with the Colts and was productive there over a much longer stretch. fukk are you even talking about.

Maybe I should've put it this way,whatever grade you gave him with the colts after he won that superbowl 10 years ago should be the same one you give him on Denver...he cant just be a bum now if you didn't think he was a bum in his last years in Indy.

I give him a O grade for overated...great at putting up numbers and padding stats,but not so great when it comes time to win when it counts and shyt gets ruff....he's the Lebron of the NFL

 

[Supa]

using your logic I guess every other qb that has ever played regular seasons dosent count neither


give a man who threw over 50+ touchdowns a d rating brehs.

Every other QB isn't considered the GOAT.

When you are considered an elite you are judged by playoff performance and rings. Who cares about 50 TD's when you damn near got shut out in the Super Bowl? You think Jordan would care about a scoring title without a ring?

 

[King Poetic]

C...

Broncos was non existent from 98 till he really got there..

But being a raiders fan im glad they never won

 

[Danny Up]

Every other QB isn't considered the GOAT.

When you are considered an elite you are judged by playoff performance and rings. Who cares about 50 TD's when you damn near got shut out in the Super Bowl? You think Jordan would care about a scoring title without a ring?

Jordan has only 6 rings in like 15 years and about 13 scoring titles. 5 losing seasons as well.

 

[yseJ]

Broncos was non existent from 98 till he really got there..

so them going 13-3 and to AFC championship in 05 was non-existent ?

 

[GunRanger]

OK, Skip. Negged.

everything I said was factual. Tell me where I'm wrong. :unsatisfied:

 

[Champ_KW]

A....can't go A+ though without a ring.
We're a monster season from AD away from Peyton having 2 back to back MVPs, TD record, 3 straight Division titles, 1 Conference title, and a SB appearance.....all while being fresh of neck surgery at the age of 38. I thought he was done when he first put the glove on cause he can't completely grip the ball. He's exceeded my expectations. Especially seeing how average Rodgers looked today when his ability to move around the pocket is taken away. Taking away a QB best attributes changes their effectiveness. It's truly amazing that he accomplished what he did with a noodle for an arm and no grip without a glove. Clap for him.

 

[CodeBlaMeVi]

B. Broke record, won lots of game and had a Super Bowl appearance at the expense of Tom Brady.

 

[Supa]

Jordan has only 6 rings in like 15 years and about 13 scoring titles. 5 losing seasons as well.

17 seasons 1 ring

 

[MenacingMonk]

Gonna retire with 1 ring.

 

[Playa With Tha Passport]

Peyton is the goat

 

[Playa With Tha Passport]

17 seasons 1 ring

5 mvps

 

[Absolut]

C+

he breezes through the early and middle course work only to fukk up the heavily weighted final exam and ruin the grade each season

 

[Maluma]

A
he came back from a damn neck injury. and he damn near 40 years old. the fukk yall expect from him.

no surprise a kobe stan would give the forehead an A

 

[Konnan]

B-