Grade Peyton Mannings Bronco career

[RubioTheCruel]

2012 they should have went to the SB, awful loss to the Ravens at home in divisional round
2013 destroyed in SB by the better team
2014 destroyed at home by Colts in divisional round, Manning has noodle arm

I dunno, B? They did win the conference and got Tebow off the team so that's something

 

[torcher]

Maybe I'll change it 2 a B-

 

[jadden]

Never missed the playoffs with him
They've lost like 3 regular season home games with him
Broke numerous NFL records
Sent Brady's bytch ass home
Made it to a super bowl

I'll give him a B/B+

 

[PortCityProphet]

A
he came back from a damn neck injury. and he damn near 40 years old. the fukk yall expect from him.

 

[The War Report]

B+

 

[Richard Wright]

If youre talking about overall its a c-, he continued to be a regular season stats guy.

However, he did prove to all of us that he could still play. A lot of folks thought he was done three years ago. He deserves serious props/ an A for that.

Averages to a B

 

[onelastdeath]

C+ dude has an amazing offense. Just couldn't get rid of the playoff bug. Just like old times. Great in the reg season. Game drops in the offs

 

[IWasntMadeToPlayTheSon]

with respect to my fantasy team he has been an A+ the last 3 yrs

 

[Supa]

They brought him in to win a championship. He failed.

F

 

[CrimsonTider]

Their best team was 2012 and Fox sabotaged that playoff game against the Ravens.

I'd give Peyton a B. Still got to a Super Bowl, won an MVP and revived the franchise.

Their best team was last years team

 

[Tommy Sheppard]

D

2012 was an D
2013 was a C
2014 was an F

so it's D

 

[jadillac]

A-

Y'all act like what he does is easy for every other QB.

Put it this way 95% of the leagues owners would love to have the results Peyton has had in Denver. .

 

[kp404]

:Peytonohsoflabnsick:F

 

[thenatural]

B+/A-

 

[GunRanger]

B -

Broncos really weren't popping before he got there.

They had a great offense last year but got stuck in SB.

Tebow had the sports world on pins and needles. broncos were must see tv, and he won a playoff.


Trading him broke my heart, and I never liked Peyton to begin with.


He gets a C, because the standards are higher for someone people call the GOAT