Grade Peyton Mannings Bronco career

[calh45]

Solid B+. He got them to two Super Bowls in 4 years. Some of y'all gonna try to throw shade on him for that Seattle game (That D played out of their minds that game) and how old he's played this season, but that's one hell of a return on investment even if he doesn't win one......if he wins Sunday (which ain't even likely) then it'll get bumped to an A

 

[Stone]

7 minutes? lol...that's an eternity in the NFL. Enough time for 3-4 more possessions even in the first and third quarters(i.e., not the end of a half) of a football game.


And again, take away 2 special returns TDs (which are of anomalous nature to begin with) and he's not even tying the game with that TD. And Raheem Moore's defensive miscue has nothing to do with the QB throwing the game sealing interception (on a terrible throw) in OT.

The mistake you make here is that you take out those return TDs and assume the Broncos wouldn't have scored when he was shredding BMore's defense until Knowshon went out and the protection started to break down in the second half.

You can't just take out something in the middle of the game and assume that everything else follows the exact same script.

 

[Stone]

But it isn't Brady v Manning in Denver, it's been Brady v Denver's altitude, which is what you fail to understand. The last 2 AFCCG between them you could've put a back up QB (even Tebow) in Peyton's place and the Broncos still win because of their biological HFA.

Let's not forget that Brady took a very untalented 2006 team to an upset over the #1 Chargers and then had the Colts on the ropes in the AFCCG before a series of questionable PI calls brought Indy back from the dead.

Tom threw what should have been the game ending pick in that Chargers game and Troy Brown brought him back from the dead by forcing a fumble. Stop it.

 

[feelosofer]

He should have taken the 49ers offer, he'd have won one maybe 2 rings already.

 

[JameisNewton]

The mistake you make here is assuming the Broncos wouldn't have scored is that you take out those return TDs and assume the Broncos wouldn't have scored when he was
shredding BMore's defense until Knowshon went out and the protection started to break down in the second half.

You can't just take out something in the middle of the game and assume that everything else follows the exact same script.

This is just a pitiful attempt to cover up that Peyton threw the game ending interception in OT and just had an overall subpar game considering he had just shredded this same defense in Baltimore 3 weeks prior. Maybe if he plays a little better during regulation they're up by more than 7 points before the hail mary.

 

[JameisNewton]

Tom threw what should have been the game ending pick in that Chargers game and Troy Brown brought him back from the dead by forcing a fumble. Stop it.

And even still, no one would fault him for losing that game as his team was a huge underdog. You don't understand the concept of house money do you?

 

[KOBE]

B in regular season? ????

You can't take some of these guys seriously breh. Most dominant regular season QB ever, and it's not remotely close, and yet he's a B in the regular season.

Like he doesn't have 5 regular season MVPs.


edit: my bad, this is broncos career. Still has a MVP with the best passing season ever.

 

[JameisNewton]

it wasnt 7 minutes. it was less than 1 minute. cause once we got the ball back after that possession we just kneed and went into OT

edit: 43 seconds left on the clock

Please read the quote I posted.

"He threw the go ahead td with 7 minutes left before Raheem Moore made the worst defensive mistake by a db I've ever seen to gift wrap the tie to Baltimore"

and for further reference: Ravens vs. Broncos - Game Summary - January 12, 2013 - ESPN

TD
7:18
Demaryius Thomas 17 Yard Pass From Peyton Manning
10 plays, 77 yards, 4:58
28 34

XP
7:11
Matt Prater Kick is Good
10 plays, 77 yards, 4:58
28 35

Peyton got the ball back before the hail mary and couldn't even pick up a first down to ice the game.

 

[Ineedmoney504]

Please read the quote I posted.

"He threw the go ahead td with 7 minutes left before Raheem Moore made the worst defensive mistake by a db I've ever seen to gift wrap the tie to Baltimore"

and for further reference: Ravens vs. Broncos - Game Summary - January 12, 2013 - ESPN

TD
7:18
Demaryius Thomas 17 Yard Pass From Peyton Manning
10 plays, 77 yards, 4:58
28 34

XP
7:11
Matt Prater Kick is Good
10 plays, 77 yards, 4:58
28 35

Peyton got the ball back before the hail mary and couldn't even pick up a first down to ice the game.

So what? We Ran the ball and killed they timeouts and gave our defense a 7 point lead wit like a minute left in the game and no timeouts, and they had to go 70 yards down field

 

[Stone]

This is just a pitiful attempt to cover up that Peyton threw the game ending interception in OT and just had an overall subpar game considering he had just shredded this same defense in Baltimore 3 weeks prior. Maybe if he plays a little better during regulation they're up by more than 7 points before the hail mary.

#2 defense in the league gave up 31 points including the game tying score when the other teams only option was a Hail Mary and we giving them a pass? Nah.

 

[Womb Raider]

My nikka won the Super Bowl


y'all better start running them A's

 

[Bless't]

A

 

[T.he I.nformant]

He should have taken the 49ers offer, he'd have won one maybe 2 rings already.

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

Easy A.

 

[unit321]

Two 1 and dones and a Super Bowl appearance.

I give it a C-

Well, he's established himself as an elite quarterback, he's earned tons of money.



Probably hit some 'cash money' contract escalators, multiple times, that we don't even know about. That's why he was so cool about hydrating on camera.