How can there be a divine plan and free will at the same time?

Berniewood Hogan

IT'S BERNIE SANDERS WITH A STEEL CHAIR!
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
17,983
Reputation
6,755
Daps
88,338
Reppin
nWg
observation actually has an impact on probability.
THIS MISCONCEPTION STEMS FROM WEAK JOURNALISM ABOUT RESEARCH ON SUBATOMIC PHENOMENA, BROTHER! WHEN THINGS ARE THAT TINY, THE ONLY WAY TO DETERMINE THEIR PRESENCE AND MEASURE THEIR MOVEMENT IS BY HITTING THEM WITH OTHER THINGS, DUDE! SEEING AN APPLE WITH YOUR EYEBALLS IS NOT THE SAME THING AS "OBSERVING" QUANTUM STUFF, MEAN GENE!
 

joeychizzle

光復香港,時代革命
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
12,078
Reputation
4,170
Daps
32,532
Reppin
852
You'll never be free of any of these because the government has its foot on our throats.
It's bad enough the government watching us, we're supposed to believe some invisible dude in the sky is watching us and waiting for us to fukk up so he can throw us in a fiery ass pit?
nah.
 

Broke Wave

The GOAT
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
18,704
Reputation
4,580
Daps
44,606
Reppin
Open Society Foundation
THIS MISCONCEPTION STEMS FROM WEAK JOURNALISM ABOUT RESEARCH ON SUBATOMIC PHENOMENA, BROTHER! WHEN THINGS ARE THAT TINY, THE ONLY WAY TO DETERMINE THEIR PRESENCE AND MEASURE THEIR MOVEMENT IS BY HITTING THEM WITH OTHER THINGS, DUDE! SEEING AN APPLE WITH YOUR EYEBALLS IS NOT THE SAME THING AS "OBSERVING" QUANTUM STUFF, MEAN GENE!

Interesting, I learned something new.
 

Majestyx

Duck Season
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,083
Reputation
2,879
Daps
42,728
Reppin
Los Scandalous
THIS MISCONCEPTION STEMS FROM WEAK JOURNALISM ABOUT RESEARCH ON SUBATOMIC PHENOMENA, BROTHER! WHEN THINGS ARE THAT TINY, THE ONLY WAY TO DETERMINE THEIR PRESENCE AND MEASURE THEIR MOVEMENT IS BY HITTING THEM WITH OTHER THINGS, DUDE! SEEING AN APPLE WITH YOUR EYEBALLS IS NOT THE SAME THING AS "OBSERVING" QUANTUM STUFF, MEAN GENE!
its annoying as shyt when people apply quantum physics and mechanics to miscellaneous stuff
 

Poh SIti Dawn

Staying Positive, Getting Better Everyday. Holler!
Joined
Feb 8, 2013
Messages
13,827
Reputation
-2,866
Daps
17,252
Reppin
NULL
It's bad enough the government watching us, we're supposed to believe some invisible dude in the sky is watching us and waiting for us to fukk up so he can throw us in a fiery ass pit?
nah.
Lool why do people think about this stuff, just live your lives and be more awesome
 

joeychizzle

光復香港,時代革命
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
12,078
Reputation
4,170
Daps
32,532
Reppin
852
Lool why do people think about this stuff, just live your lives and be more awesome
One of the most marvelous defining traits of mankind is the burning curiosity which drives us to seek what is hidden to us. My ancestors possessed this curiosity, and your ancestors possessed this curiosity. I have simply cast myself free of bias that disallows me to seek true answers. My thirst for answers is unquenchable breh. I cannot simply believe that a book, coincidentally a book that has been proven wrong, has all the answers I need to live an awesome life.

Watch through the wormhole with MF and/or cosmos with NDT and I'd be utterly shocked at how anyone who was still a theist after watching them.
People with closed minds will reject facts because they directly contradict what they have been taught. Crucial thought and questioning isn't encouraged within religious communities, except when it comes to methods of glorifying their 'saviours' and methods of extracting money from other religious folk in their names.

Many won't even accept portrayals of their religious idols. I tried to watch a film about Jesus called The Man From Earth (worth a watch - it's not what you expect) with a highly religious friend and he snapped and stormed out of the room at a certain point in the film.

You should give it a watch breh. If you do, don't read the plot or synposis. Just torrent that shyt and sit back and wait for the :ohhh: and the :whoo: and the :to: at the end.

Wow I just checked IMDB and it's got an 8/10 :ohhh:
 

GSR

All Star
Joined
Jun 27, 2012
Messages
1,761
Reputation
710
Daps
6,706
Reppin
daygo
To answer the OP:

The universe is God. Each of us is literally a piece of God viewing/experiencing itself.

Having a divine plan and free will makes perfect sense. Each of our free wills is divine and part of the plan.

Therefore we each have divine will.

The iron knee is that most of us aren't aware of it and we walking around thinking we're just human doing human mundane shyt.
 

hayesc0

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
38,507
Reputation
8,353
Daps
118,861
To answer the OP:

The universe is God. Each of us is literally a piece of God viewing/experiencing itself.

Having a divine plan and free will makes perfect sense. Each of our free wills is divine and part of the plan.

Therefore we each have divine will.

The iron knee is that most of us aren't aware of it and we walking around thinking we're just human doing human mundane shyt.
:russ::laff::deadmanny: WTF does this mean.
 

NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
46,332
Reputation
5,976
Daps
94,038
Reppin
Uncertain grounds

If god has everything planned, why the fukk does he say we have free will? :leostare:

That's like going to a theme park with your kids and saying, "You can do whatever you want, but if you don't do as I say, you're gonna get punished."

:what:


i had a (surprisingly) decent debate with 2 pretty religious christians about this actually. they differed in their opinions and had debates with each other about it.

by decent, i mean that it wasnt just pure bible thumping and emotional..they used logic to back up their religious beliefs more than i had expected.

i said (essentially) that it was impossible to have both simultaneously

one said that there is the divine plan and that everyone has free-will to follow it or not

the other said that free will was given when humanity fell from grace and that there is limited free-will (?) in that God doesnt make decisions for them but that if they act with selflessness and "good" intentions (based on that person's religious tenets specifically, but he granted that other religions arent necessarily false or frowned upon unless other people do bad things intentionally) then they can be in step with the divine plan and in grace without really even knowing it.

i basically responded by saying...if the above is true..then wouldn't free will just be an illusion under that logic? if the divine plan is primary..then wouldnt the free will seemingly exercised already have been pre-determined? So how would there be free will in any given moment if the beginning and end/future have already been scripted out completely? the general response was that people have the choice to be in step with the plan and grace but that there have been so many beings to have existed in the past, currently exist and will exist in the future..plus everything else that has happened, is happening and will happen in general...that 99.999% of individuals do not have enough individual influence or significance to alter the divine plan one way or another and for every one person that doesnt choose to be in grace there is one person that does and everything eventually balances out.

i figured that arguing too much wouldnt really lead to anything and just wanted to get their opinions on it. i disagreed that they can both exist at the same time but found their responses to be interesting despite them side-stepping some things to better fit their stances :manny: one admitted to having some doubt and i pushed him on that and asked if he thought he was truly saved yet based on his own religion and i think he had to pause and think about that for a second
 

joeychizzle

光復香港,時代革命
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
12,078
Reputation
4,170
Daps
32,532
Reppin
852
i had a (surprisingly) decent debate with 2 pretty religious christians about this actually. they differed in their opinions and had debates with each other about it.

by decent, i mean that it wasnt just pure bible thumping and emotional..they used logic to back up their religious beliefs more than i had expected.

i said (essentially) that it was impossible to have both simultaneously

one said that there is the divine plan and that everyone has free-will to follow it or not

the other said that free will was given when humanity fell from grace and that there is limited free-will (?) in that God doesnt make decisions for them but that if they act with selflessness and "good" intentions (based on that person's religious tenets specifically, but he granted that other religions arent necessarily false or frowned upon unless other people do bad things intentionally) then they can be in step with the divine plan and in grace without really even knowing it.

i basically responded by saying...if the above is true..then wouldn't free will just be an illusion under that logic? if the divine plan is primary..then wouldnt the free will seemingly exercised already have been pre-determined? So how would there be free will in any given moment if the beginning and end/future have already been scripted out completely? the general response was that people have the choice to be in step with the plan and grace but that there have been so many beings to have existed in the past, currently exist and will exist in the future..plus everything else that has happened, is happening and will happen in general...that 99.999% of individuals do not have enough individual influence or significance to alter the divine plan one way or another and for every one person that doesnt choose to be in grace there is one person that does and everything eventually balances out.

i figured that arguing too much wouldnt really lead to anything and just wanted to get their opinions on it. i disagreed that they can both exist at the same time but found their responses to be interesting despite them side-stepping some things to better fit their stances :manny: one admitted to having some doubt and i pushed him on that and asked if he thought he was truly saved yet based on his own religion and i think he had to pause and think about that for a second
Your patience is much higher than mine breh. Ultimately, debating such things with theists, just ain't productive. They can twist facts to suit their argument and will ignore and/or deny things just to shut you up. Atheists don't have the luxury of bending truths.

And most religious folk I've met don't go far beyond 1. I feel it in my heart 2. The book is correct because the book says so 3. Don't you dare question (insert religious name here) 4. They name an experience which to them unquestionably validates God, despite the situation being completely within the confines of humanity/nature.
 

joeychizzle

光復香港,時代革命
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
12,078
Reputation
4,170
Daps
32,532
Reppin
852
We're also born without the ability to walk, talk, eat and drink on our own etc...,

That doesnt mean the knowledge gained is irrelevant :ehh:

Then how come your religion is defined by one location? North America and south America, usually Christian. Middle East, Muslim. Israel, Jewish. Asia, often Buddhist.

If I was a God, I wouldn't let other religions claim to be the real deal. It's not like smartphones where you can have android or apple or Windows phone or even BlackBerry:mjlol:

Can you imagine if a company tried to directly copy a competitor's product, but then tried to say that their methods and ingredients weren't the same, yet tried to pass off their copy as real, and claim all credit and and profits? That's religion. Except there is no real product.

But i'll wait for you to say that all other religions are man-made and the Torah is obviously the one true book.
 

Drip Bayless

Superstar
Joined
Jun 1, 2014
Messages
13,080
Reputation
2,927
Daps
56,382
Why are you guys so hung up on proving religion is false? You're not going to convince a theist otherwise so the atheist circle jerk is not very productive. I'm agnostic and knowing how little I truly know is good enough for me.
 
Top