That may have some truth to it, but every overweight woman I have delt with ( and im not talking about fat wales, just chicks that can stand to lose about 20 lbs) they have bad eating habits, they have this sweet tooth that has to be fed, they eat their "comfort foods" when they feel a certain way, and IF they do go to the gym they only want to get on the treadmill and eliptical, they aint touching weight because they think that even tho they dont build muscle like us, they are going to skip over being lean and in good shape to being she hulk from using 10lbs weights. The TS and all these fat haters speak alot of truth in this thread, your scenario probably only speaks to the few exceptions to the rule not the majority.