How do you rank the Roots discography best to worst?

Rekkapryde

GT, LWO, 49ERS, BRAVES, HAWKS, N4O...yeah UMAD!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
158,905
Reputation
31,453
Daps
539,439
Reppin
TYRONE GA!
Won’t rank the “best”, but these are my favorites in order of my desire to listen to them again and again.

Things Fall Apart/Undun
Illadelph Halflife/How I Got Over/Phrenology
Do You Want More
Game Theory
Rising Down (goat roots intro track lol)
The Tipping Point
And Then You'll Shoot Your Cousin

When Phrenology dropped my older sister’s fiance bought it for me. I liked a few tracks but could never really get into it. Listening to it now makes me wonder what the fukk was wrong with me. It’s quickly become one of my favorite Roots albums. It was amazing how effortlessly Black Thought was rhyming over such a varied, but cohesive album.

Good ranking.

Undun didn't do it for me on my first listen. Haven't really gone back to it. Will check it back out.

TFA is still their best joint to me, followed closely by Halflife. HIGO was their best joint in a while when it dropped even though I did like their 2000s albums. Malik not being on them aside a few joints on Rising Down and Game Theory really sucked. Losing Hub also put a dent in the group to me even though he didn't rap. Rahzel as well being gone.


The last studio album didn't do it for me either (Shoot your cousin).

Overall though, still one of my favorite groups ever and Thought is in my Personal Top 10 MCs ever.
 

The Intergalactic Koala

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
67,579
Reputation
27,052
Daps
276,726
Reppin
Extinct
Rising Down/Up>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Everything else

I'm sorry but Def Jam brought the best out The Roots. The experimental sounds, the Philly/DMV vibes, and the dedication to Dilla made those albums feel surreal.
 

987654321

Superstar
Joined
Jun 15, 2018
Messages
9,966
Reputation
5,160
Daps
35,542
Good ranking.

Undun didn't do it for me on my first listen. Haven't really gone back to it. Will check it back out.

TFA is still their best joint to me, followed closely by Halflife. HIGO was their best joint in a while when it dropped even though I did like their 2000s albums. Malik not being on them aside a few joints on Rising Down and Game Theory really sucked. Losing Hub also put a dent in the group to me even though he didn't rap. Rahzel as well being gone.


The last studio album didn't do it for me either (Shoot your cousin).

Overall though, still one of my favorite groups ever and Thought is in my Personal Top 10 MCs ever.

Up until last year I would always put rising down above game theory. Older me finds parts of Rising down musically repetitive, but there’s a bunch of songs I really love on there.
 
Top