How many classics does Eminem have ? (poll)

[MINT]

I saw this thread on boxden and I wanted to know your opinion about that.

the popular opinion is that Eminem has 3 classics, what do you think ?

 

[MINT]

2 or 3

 

[MINT]

3

TSSLP, TMMLP and TES

and you can have an argument that TMMLP is top 3 of all time

 

[James Carter]

The first three albums are classic but you could replace infinite with the eminem show depending on if you feel the beats on infinite are dated and like serious em on the eminem show. Everything post eminem show is trash tho

 

[MINT]

I'll go with 3.
He has more classic than Jay and Nas

 

[Layla Hunnam]

2 non-debatable classics. TES is kinda debatable.

To me he has 3 though.

 

[thekidfromqueens]

mmlp, tes, arguably sslp. he also has one of the most prolific falloffs ever though. some of these punchlines now ....

 

[villain]

where da fukk is zero

 

[DaveyDave]

maybe MMLP but it's replay value isn't high for me. that's the closest tho, i'd say 0

 

[dunkman6]

I fukks with Infinite heavy.

SSLP is dope too. I'll take TES over MMLP.

MMLP is overrated to me.

 

[Busby]

3...Slim Shady and Marshall Mathers LP...and TES...and that is up for no debate..

 

[No1]

I'll go with 3.
He has more classic than Jay and Nas

AND JUST LIKE THAT, your hip hop opinion on this board will never be taken seriously again.

Shady's problem is replay value. It's hard to listen to the entirety of SSLP or the MMLP these days. TES actually aged the best. It's hard for me to call. What I felt then vs. what I feel now

I can only give him one.

 

[delnegro]

0

 

[aRoMaN21]

u didnt put 6 so i couldnt vote

 

[dunkman6]

u didnt put 6 so i couldnt vote