A lot of dudes yearn for the return of boom bap
Here's the thing about boom bap
People get it confused with Golden Era, East Coast boom bap is immediately post Golden Era
Boom Bap crystallized around Enter The Wu-Tang, Illmatic and The Infamous. You can throw in Enta Da Stage if you want.
Boom Bap's fatal flaw was that it was catered to only one type of listener
They used to call these dudes "hardrocks" on the east coast
This type of dude typically hugged the block all day and night
Smoked weed and drank throughout most days, didnt hold a job or bring in substantial income
Gross estimate 60% of these types were in the street life; the rest being teenagers or college aged young adults
The aforementioned albums were by hardrocks and spoke directly to the hard rock experience
Which at the time was new
Boom Bap conveniently forgot the roots of hip hop
Hip Hop originated as a party sub culture
The objective was to turn the party out through b-boying, deejaying, and emceeing
The main problem with Boom Bap is that not everyone is a hard rock
Boom Bap's doubling down on the machismo was a direct reaction to the rise of West Coast gangsta rap in the late 80's-early 90's
In the aftermath of Straight Out of Compton, the East was embarrassed to realize that their current reigning champs were the Native Tongue crew and acts influenced by that vibe
So NY rappers went about butching it up to defend their street rep
Musically, Boom Bap was reactionary in the sound of the music itself.
When the reviled West Coast gangsta emcees embraced funk music, Boom Bap reacted by dismissing funk and any other groove based music even though they had been cool with it previously
Boom bap chose to sample jazz and eventually anything abstract because the drums were the main focus
Boom bap tried to make the music as dark and menacing sounding as possible to back up the attitude of the emcees and their subject matter
By doing so, they squeezed all the soul and groove out of the music
B-boys couldnt bug out to this music. Women were displaced altogether
The hardrocks loved it.
Because of the underserved audiences left behind by boom bap, Puff was able to easily slide in and dominate by serving both audiences at the same time.
To this day, he has not been forgiven by certain segments of hip hop society for quashing the dominance of Boom Bap with his fairly obvious brainstorm
TL;DR - Boom Bap was destined to be short lived because it was for and by street dudes and left everyone else in the cold. Because of that flaw, boom bap will not dominate again like it once did for a brief period post Golden Era