How would you rate micheal Vicks passing?
- Thread starter The 10th Letter
- Start date
Majestic Pape
The-Coli = W SOHH = L
I could maybe rock with this if you said top 10 passer top 5 QB
Vick's 2010 season was better than any season Romo or Eli ever put together. As for the others you named, no. Vick has proved his peak is only met by Brady, Peyton, AR & Brees. Its just up in the air if he can get back to that level.
FreedS[ohh]lave
Banned
Vick's 2010 season was better than any season Romo or Eli ever put together. As for the others you named, no. Vick has proved his peak is only met by Brady, Peyton, AR & Brees. Its just up in the air if he can get back to that level.
Hes had one elite season which was 2010..the top qb's have had numeorus ones dont compare him to them..
his career has been one good season followed by one bad or medicore one for almost a decade! he is what he is..an explosive but inconsistent QB..
The fact that he was out of the league doing NOTHING for 2+ years....it's astounding how he's been able to play at such a high level. Folk don't seem to really talk about that. Dude missed 2 seasons of football...was on the bench for another year and played part of the next season.
Wild!
Wild!
The 10th Letter
Rookie
Even after I asked them to take this into account they chose to ignore it. The usual Suspects too. Lol
feelosofer
#ninergang
When he was on the Falcons, he was an incredible athlete but a shyt passer despite having the arm strength. Somehow he rotted in jail came back 2 years later and became a pretty good passer and still has most of his athleticism. I would say he is a top 15 passer, but a top 10 playmaker. He is still a very good QB.
Arm strength- Amazing
Accuracy- Average
Decision-making- Poor
The nikka has never been consistent passer.
at nikkas putting him top 5 or top 10. nikkas are so caught up in that video game start to last season that they are totally ignoring what's happened since (28 td 20 in 60 or so % completion) or before. He's shown flashes but consistency is what makes a guy good/great. He's average until he proves otherwise.
Accuracy- Average
Decision-making- Poor
The nikka has never been consistent passer.
at nikkas putting him top 5 or top 10. nikkas are so caught up in that video game start to last season that they are totally ignoring what's happened since (28 td 20 in 60 or so % completion) or before. He's shown flashes but consistency is what makes a guy good/great. He's average until he proves otherwise.Arm strength- Amazing
Accuracy- Average
Decision-making- Poor
The nikka has never been consistent passer.
Man, I remember when nikkaz had him as the top QB in the league back in 2010....I was called a goon cuz I disagreed.
He's not average, though. He's above average....but like you said, you can't be considered great or even good without consistency.
FreedS[ohh]lave;828819 said:
Doesn't matter. Eli or Romo never had a season like that. You can say you'd take Eli or Romo's stability over Vick all you want
but, don't you dare say they're more talented after the unrealistic shyt Vick was doing in 2010.
yseJ
Empire strikes back
he surprised the fukk out of me with his passing in 2010. I guess he caught lots of people by surprise. the next year the league adjusted and glimpses of old vick re-appeared.
like jlova said, consistency is pretty important. vick is pretty good, but hes not a top 5 passer.
like jlova said, consistency is pretty important. vick is pretty good, but hes not a top 5 passer.
Mandizi
5-I-3 till I D-I-E
Yeah, this.
Top 15-18 passer.
Top 10 QB.
As an overall QB, Killa Cam is already on his level if not better tho after one season(which is scary).
