If wrestling Kayfabe was legit (like boxing) who is the P4P GOAT

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

this spun off the brock/cena finish thread...

if he beats cena for the strap, brock will have high profile wins over:

• hogan
• hhh
• undertaker
• cena
• rock

who are like...kayfabe gods. he will have made everyone bow down. and be champ, and not even care about the sport.

is there anyone who could be considered the kayfabe P4P GOAT over him?

 

[Mook]

If we're talking about right now. Cena would be selling 3 million in ppvs cause that fakkit is 100x floyd who never loses

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

We've went over this before.

It's Warrior, followed closely by prime Hogan and Goldberg.

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

If we're talking about right now. Cena would be selling 3 million in ppvs cause that fakkit is 100x floyd who never loses

But he wouldn't be as big a draw as brock lesnar...or even daniel bryan...Cena would be Vitaly and Wladimir Klichko

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

We've went over this before.

It's Warrior, followed by closely be prime Hogan and Goldberg.

...now that you mention warrior...yeah we did this before. we can lock/merge this...not here to clutter.

and brock would be over hogan easily because he has a CLEAN win over him...warrior / goldberg is arguable though

 

[Mook]

But he wouldn't be as big a draw as brock lesnar...or even daniel bryan...Cena would be Vitaly and Wladimir Klichko

Nah cause the division in real heavyweight sucks. But WWE HW division would be fire. Daniel and Brock have to go through Cena. Realistically Brock would be the underdog since he lost the first match.

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

...now that you mention warrior...yeah we did this before. we can lock/merge this...not here to clutter.

and brock would be over hogan easily because he has a CLEAN win over him...warrior / goldberg is arguable though

Brock beat old man Hogan more than 12 years removed from his prime.

When Hulkamania was at it's peak Brock would have got steamrolled just like everybody else.

 

[Beautiful Bobby Eatin]

But he wouldn't be as big a draw as brock lesnar...or even daniel bryan...Cena would be Vitaly and Wladimir Klichko

Right now Cena but if Brock wins its him hands down.

But Warrior only lost three times

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

Brock beat old man Hogan more than 12 years removed from his prime.

When Hulkamania was at it's peak Brock would have got steamrolled just like everybody else.

he might've been ludvig borga status

 

[Beautiful Bobby Eatin]

Brock beat old man Hogan more than 12 years removed from his prime.

When Hulkamania was at it's peak Brock would have got steamrolled just like everybody else.

Thats kinda still thinking in kayfabe breh. Hogan won to sell merch. Brock's real attributes are off the charts. Its like dude really has the Super Soldier serum

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

Warrior took 5 elbow drops from Savage and still kicked out.

He took the pedigree from HHH and literally danced it off.

The guy was virtually unbeatable.

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

Thats kinda still thinking in kayfabe breh. Hogan won to sell merch. Brock's real attributes are off the charts. Its like dude really has the Super Soldier serum

Your level of overness runs parallel to how you are booked.

When Hogan was on top of the world no one was going over him. No one. Brock would have been just another in a long line of giants that Hogan would have beat. In fact Hogan looked bigger than Brock this last Monday and he's 61. Imagine if he still had the pythons.

Brock would have got destroyed.

Only Warrior could claim that he beat Hogan clean while he was on top.

 

[MrFirst2doit]

Bruno would be the kayfabe GOAT based on title longevity...

modern times..post-85... John Cena would be most dominant champ..15 world championships in 10 years...

 

[PYRRHUS 88]

Goldberg and Warrior both crushed their way to the top, but their lack of title defenses might hurt them in a P4P goat discussion

Cena or Hogan have the best resume. Cena has like 1000 title defenses, and Hogan has wins over prime Savage, prime-ish Andre, prime Yokozuna, prime Sid, a still elite HBK, etc etc. Check his record against Flair:

In their first 21 meetings, Hogan won 17 matches and Flair won four

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

Bruno would be the kayfabe GOAT based on title longevity...

modern times..post-85... John Cena would be most dominant champ..15 world championships in 10 years...

Cena lost clean to Randy Orton and Daniel Bryan. That disqualifies him from the discussion.

Cena's dominance is a result of him beating on bums in a watered down era.