If wrestling Kayfabe was legit (like boxing) who is the P4P GOAT

[Beautiful Bobby Eatin]

Your level of overness runs parallel to how you are booked.

When Hogan was on top of the world no one was going over him. No one. Brock would have been just another in a long line of giants that Hogan would have beat. In fact Hogan looked bigger than Brock this last Monday and he's 61. Imagine if he still had the pythons.

Brock would have got destroyed.

Only Warrior could claim that he beat Hogan clean while he was on top.

In the rule of wrestling yes. But to give it the realism of boxing the draw is the guy who wins and is usually the most talented. If I had to build the ultimate CAW it is Brock Lesnar.

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

Cena lost clean to Randy Orton and Daniel Bryan. That disqualifies him from the discussion.

Cena's dominance is a result of him beating on bums in a watered down era.

and all the top tier guys he face (the afformentioned orton and bryan...CM Punk...BROCK on sunday) he at best exchanged wins and losses...

 

[Kimo_bud]

Prime 80s hogan was virtually unbeatable

 

[El Guapo]

Goldberg.

• Lost like what less than a handful of matches in WCW.
• Never lost a one on one match in WWE.
• The streak.
• High profile wins over Hogan, Sting, Giant, Steiner, Rock, Triple H and Brock.

 

[Miggs]

Your level of overness runs parallel to how you are booked.

When Hogan was on top of the world no one was going over him. No one. Brock would have been just another in a long line of giants that Hogan would have beat. In fact Hogan looked bigger than Brock this last Monday and he's 61. Imagine if he still had the pythons.

Brock would have got destroyed.

Only Warrior could claim that he beat Hogan clean while he was on top.

Hogans prime 84-88
He was equal billing with Warrior WM 6 so Warrior dont even have that...

Warrior in 85-86 wasnt going over Hogan...

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

Just wanna touch more on Brock not being able to hang with Hogan (in kayfabe).

This was like 12 years ago.

The muthafukka is basically bigger than he is.

And you guys think Lesnar would even have a CHANCE of "conquering" this?

They didn't call him HULK Hogan for no damn reason.

I'm sorry Brock ain't beatin this dude.

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

Hogans prime 84-88
He was equal billing with Warrior WM 6 so Warrior dont even have that...

Warrior in 85-86 wasnt going over Hogan...

No doubt that's true but Hogan was still technically in his "prime" in 1990.

Warrior co-headlined not because Hogan's star was fading in any way but because his was rising. Hogan was still very much "the man" by WM6.

 

[FreshAIG]

Andre The Giant

 

[Ed MOTHEREFFING G]

Just wanna touch more on Brock not being able to hang with Hogan (in kayfabe).

This was like 12 years ago.

The muthafukka is basically bigger than he is.

And you guys think Lesnar would even have a CHANCE of "conquering" this?

They didn't call him HULK Hogan for no damn reason.

I'm sorry Brock ain't beatin this dude.

low key, people REGUARLY forget how big hogan is...he has a wide frame, is real tall, and STAYS yoked out. Dude is bigger than warrior...wrestlemania 1-3 hogan was JACKED

 

[Miggs]

No doubt that's true but Hogan was still technically in his "prime" in 1990.

Warrior co-headlined not because Hogan's star was fading in any way but because his was rising. Hogan was still very much "the man" by WM6.

I dont agree i thnk he had faded by 89-90 and with Savage and Warrior getting at least equal billing at main events that much was obvious...Hogan around the time wasnt the same at all as mid 80s Hogan in terms of pop...Fans were ready to pass the torch.

You could say he was still main eventing and was still holding the belt after Savage took it BUT
it didnt feel the same at all....He definitely had faded at the time WM 6,mere fact others were getting equal pop and competing with him is proof of that...

 

[Miggs]

Prime 80s hogan was virtually unbeatable

Prime 80s Hogan i think lost 1 match via count out and that was before the first Wrestlemania and rock n wrestling took hold...After that they wouldnt let him lose for 4 years...

 

[Miggs]

Just wanna touch more on Brock not being able to hang with Hogan (in kayfabe).

This was like 12 years ago.

The muthafukka is basically bigger than he is.

And you guys think Lesnar would even have a CHANCE of "conquering" this?

They didn't call him HULK Hogan for no damn reason.

I'm sorry Brock ain't beatin this dude.

Prime Terrence was 6-8 over 300 lbs and huge everywhere II

 

[Canada Goose]

Undertaker, only lost cleanly like 6 or 7 times in a 25 year career, beat up on the heels on the roster by himself at once on several different occasions, knows MMA moves, didn't feel pain early in his career, etc.

Clean wins over
Triple H
HBK
Cena
Diesel
Big Show
Orton
Rock
Kane
Batista
Khali
Flair
He would have had a clean win over Lesnar back in 03 If coke boy didn't interfare in the match

 

[krackdagawd]

But he wouldn't be as big a draw as brock lesnar...or even daniel bryan...Cena would be Vitaly and Wladimir Klichko

Wlad and his brother are huge draws overseas.

 

[Mook]

http://d3819ii77zvwic.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/wwe.gif

I KNEW THIS fakkit WASNT 6'7

WHY IS VINCE SUCH A LIAR?