Im confused on some of the criticisms on the RGIII situation...

[Brozay]

So people on here AND in the media are criticizing his decision to come back so quickly.

Looks like a lot of the same people that KILLED Derrick Rose and his decision to not return until HE felt 100%.


I want to see some people eat crow. What do people think of Rose's decision now? What will you think of his decision when he is playing at an elite level from day one this season with no setbacks?


The whole premise that he should/could return, in the fukking playoffs of all times , was ABSOLUTE bullshyt.

So which is it?

 

[FloorGeneral]

I've been waiting for this thread

 

[red222]

well this should be fun

 

[Jplaya2023]

So people on here AND in the media are criticizing his decision to come back so quickly.

Looks like a lot of the same people that KILLED Derrick Rose and his decision to not return until HE felt 100%.


I want to see some people eat crow. What do people think of Rose's decision now? What will you think of his decision when he is playing at an elite level from day one this season with no setbacks?


The whole premise that he should/could return, in the fukking playoffs of all times , was ABSOLUTE bullshyt.

So which is it?

honestly the only people hating on rose were coli trolls who hated the bulls. The media was killing rose's brother not rose himself. Like i said i'm glad he sat out the entire year. i want him healthy for the next 10+ years

 

[red222]

So people on here AND in the media are criticizing his decision to come back so quickly.

Looks like a lot of the same people that KILLED Derrick Rose and his decision to not return until HE felt 100%.


I want to see some people eat crow. What do people think of Rose's decision now? What will you think of his decision when he is playing at an elite level from day one this season with no setbacks?


The whole premise that he should/could return, in the fukking playoffs of all times , was ABSOLUTE bullshyt.

So which is it?

The problem was no definitive answers came from him. Then his brother criticism of the roster and Bucher came out with the scoop that the roster may influence his decision to return early or not. If certain reports wouldn't have come out and along with the waffling from him imo, the criticism would have been starkly different.

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

Rose should of have just deaded any talk of him returning last year. Also AP only had like 450 yards his first 6 games. The last 10 is where he really got going. Difference is I don't remember AP's dad coming out and speaking for him or the media campaign that was waged like RG3. He did too much and set himself up for this criticism.

 

[Texas2step]

So people on here AND in the media are criticizing his decision to come back so quickly.

Looks like a lot of the same people that KILLED Derrick Rose and his decision to not return until HE felt 100%.


I want to see some people eat crow. What do people think of Rose's decision now? What will you think of his decision when he is playing at an elite level from day one this season with no setbacks?


The whole premise that he should/could return, in the fukking playoffs of all times , was ABSOLUTE bullshyt.

So which is it?

Corn G couldn't keep his mouth closed and HE said that he was 100%. He could have played in the preseason to get some rust off and be ready for the season.

Rose just kept playing with ppl's emotions talking about he "might" play this and that game. Plus the things that his brother said didnt help and confirmed what ppl thought about Rose not coming back bc he gave up on the season already. He could have played a quarter here and there and got some rust off before playoffs

You are overlooking the other factors

 

[nalej]

Hindsight is always 20/20. If RG3 came back and played well Rose would look worse right now.

 

[NV-ME]

ive been on the record since day one that rose did the right thing. its his body. nobody knows but him and if he don't feel right, he shouldn't come back. fukk that short term success and long term misery/scrutiny.

rg3 shyt is different. biggest problem in this scenario is too many talking heads. skins shoulda got w/ dr. Andrews, rg3, his pops and whoever else off top and said none of us are talking any independent shyt. we gonna play up the downside of the recovery and wait til he really ready and that alone will be the move. now everyone's 2 cent about the offense and was he really ready is being brought up. told nikkas that ap shyt last year got mofos actin like modern day medicine has turned everyone into supermen. NO, ap is a freak. cant compare anyone to him.

 

[Brozay]

honestly the only people hating on rose were coli trolls who hated the bulls. The media was killing rose's brother not rose himself. Like i said i'm glad he sat out the entire year. i want him healthy for the next 10+ years

Nah, sorry this wasnt the case. Derrick Rose was catching PLENTY of flack. Even some of the player turned analyst were getting at him.

 

[I'm Chillin]

Hindsight is always 20/20. If RG3 came back and played well Rose would look worse right now.

You can never look stupid for looking out for your health first

 

[Brozay]

See, people here are now changing the narrative.

I was steadfast in my stance that Rose was making the right decision but he and his team didnt handle it well.

There were PLENTY of people criticizing his decision to simply not play.

 

[Brozay]

ive been on the record since day one that rose did the right thing. its his body. nobody knows but him and if he don't feel right, he shouldn't come back. fukk that short term success and long term misery/scrutiny.

rg3 shyt is different. biggest problem in this scenario is too many talking heads. skins shoulda got w/ dr. Andrews, rg3, his pops and whoever else off top and said none of us are talking any independent shyt. we gonna play up the downside of the recovery and wait til he really ready and that alone will be the move. now everyone's 2 cent about the offense and was he really ready is being brought up. told nikkas that ap shyt last year got mofos actin like modern day medicine has turned everyone into supermen. NO, ap is a freak. cant compare anyone to him.

agree with these thoughts

people pitting rose/rg iii's situations to AP was simply not fair. AP is a different breed, he is a freak

 

[Texas2step]

See, people here are now changing the narrative.

I was steadfast in my stance that Rose was making the right decision but he and his team didnt handle it well.

There were PLENTY of people criticizing his decision to simply not play.

Because he gave off the impression that he could play. He said he will play when he could jump off that leg and dunk comfortably. Then you see this nikka dunking in pregame and practice like it was nothing

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

sitting out the playoffs when you're team really needs you and you are clearly able to play is a little different from rushing back from a injury way too soon and costing your team by playing like crap