Is Eddie Murphy the GOAT?

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

He could come back on the stand up circuit and murder if he wanted to

 

[Willie]

he's not the great but in top 5....Red foxx, martin, robin harris, pryor

 

[avon barksdale]

every stat the op put up martin can match them numbers...martin ran the 90's and a lil of 2000

 

[BrothaZay]

every stat the op put up martin can match them numbers...martin ran the 90's and a lil of 2000

No he cant, not even close
Only thing Martin has over Eddie is that Martin has the GOAT sitcom(at its peak)
Eddie has him in everything else and outshined him in 'Life'

 

[avon barksdale]

No he cant, not even close
Only thing Martin has over Eddie is that Martin has the GOAT sitcom(at its peak)
Eddie has him in everything else and outshined him in 'Life'

look at boomerang and tell me martin is not funnier then Eddie...Eddie did get him in life tho. And then look at Harlem nights with Eddie with the other greats i posted and then tell me is he the great.

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

I forgot how much of THAT DUDE eddie use to be.

Aint no body really been close since, on all fronts aleast (stand up, movies, music/pop culture).

-DMP-

Jamie Foxx

That stretch of Ray, Ali, Collaterel and Miami Vice(movie sucked but visual ambiance is )...Stand up was crack back in the day, tv show...He's a close 2nd to Eddie IMO and above Will Smith at this point..

Eddie to me is that nikka off the strength of Boomerang. Watched that shyt this past weekend.

 

[-DMP-]

Jamie Foxx

That stretch of Ray, Ali, Collaterel and Miami Vice(movie sucked but visual ambiance is )...Stand up was crack back in the day, tv show...He's a close 2nd to Eddie IMO and above Will Smith at this point..

Eddie to me is that nikka off the strength of Boomerang. Watched that shyt this past weekend.

forgot a bout jamie. he even had the tv show and better songs.

-DMP-

 

[BrothaZay]

look at boomerang and tell me martin is not funnier then Eddie...Eddie did get him in life tho. And then look at Harlem nights with Eddie with the other greats i posted and then tell me is he the great.

Im just saying number wise Eddie is killing martin.
1 billlion dollar movie
Highest grossing stand up ever
Number 2 song in the nation

 

[Mr. Pink]

As far as comedy goes, Patrice O'Neal>>

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

forgot a bout jamie. he even had the tv show and better songs.

-DMP-

Yeh I mean Jamie low-key might got Will, Eddie, Martin, Pryor and others by a mile

Dude put out crack music...Song a lone crushed the fukking buildings then DJ Play Me a Love Song, Unpredictable with Luda



Ron Howard, Forrest Whitaker, Jake Gyllenhall, Sam Jackson, Morris Chestnut, Bill Bellamy, JD all making cameos ....I fukks with Jamie off the strength of his support for Trayvon and his family and he showed no fukks to give about who would be upset about it.... Jamie >>>>>Eddie..My pick is reversed

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

This is now a Jamie Foxx appreciation thread

 

[Conscious Pilot]

Cant go wrong with Eddie, Martin, Chappelle, Rock or Foxx.

 

[MikeBrownsJob]

 

[avon barksdale]

Yeh I mean Jamie low-key might got Will, Eddie, Martin, Pryor and others by a mile

Dude put out crack music...Song a lone crushed the fukking buildings then DJ Play Me a Love Song, Unpredictable with Luda



Ron Howard, Forrest Whitaker, Jake Gyllenhall, Sam Jackson, Morris Chestnut, Bill Bellamy, JD all making cameos ....I fukks with Jamie off the strength of his support for Trayvon and his family and he showed no fukks to give about who would be upset about it.... Jamie >>>>>Eddie..My pick is reversed

IDK why i'm replying to this because u might be trolling...but Jamie doesn't have anything classic that would put him in the top 10. Movies,songs,stand up and sitcom is forgettable....Will,Martin and Eddie haves classic sitcoms,movies and stand ups,so Jamie

 

[mr x]

I'm doing a survey on versatile black comics...chime in http://www.thecoli.com/threads/whats-the-consensus-on-black-comics-5-smiley-rating-system.173913/