Em can rap don’t get me wrong. Better than most lyrically but with that said Big Pun was better. 
Is Eminem in your Top 10?
- Thread starter levitate
- Start date
feelosofer
#ninergang
Some of these dudes are just fishing for militant daps.
Is Em in the top 10. No.
But even though he has put out a lot of ok to decent albums he's top 25-30 off of impact and his 1st 3 albums are excellent.
Had he retired at Relapse his placement would be higher.
Is Em in the top 10. No.
But even though he has put out a lot of ok to decent albums he's top 25-30 off of impact and his 1st 3 albums are excellent.
Had he retired at Relapse his placement would be higher.
Duke Wy Lin
It's been a good run. Wish y'all the best ✊🏿
Hell nah 
Dude is all form no substance.
......Oranges
.......syringes
Nah foh
Dude is all form no substance.
......Oranges
.......syringes
Nah foh
humminbird
Veteran
he'll find this thread soon enoughWhy y'all keep making Eminem threads on this site?!!
Not you specifically OP but some dude in the booth (can't think of his name) always makes Eminem threads.
Like, who even thinks about Eminem in 2023. If it wasn't for the coli I would literally NEVER think about Eminem
No.
His music has aged like milk. No slight against him but it is what it is.
You listen to this The World Is Yours and that is great in any era. You listen to The Real Slim Shady and you want to barf.
In fairness, that that doesn't apply to everything (Till I collapse, Stan, Lose Yourself, Cleaning Out My Closet), but it is too many for me to have him a Top 10.
His music has aged like milk. No slight against him but it is what it is.
You listen to this The World Is Yours and that is great in any era. You listen to The Real Slim Shady and you want to barf.
In fairness, that that doesn't apply to everything (Till I collapse, Stan, Lose Yourself, Cleaning Out My Closet), but it is too many for me to have him a Top 10.
LeaveMyHairLineAlone
Superstar
LunaticVillage415
All Star
Em is by far the most overrated rapper of all time. Everybody saying he’s so “lyrical” when he’s one of the worst rappers musically. Horrible beats that sound like some low budget German horror movie from the 90’s. When Dre was producing for Em in the 2000’s, he had become obsessed with making beats that sounded like they were AI generated by an AOL Instant messenger robot. Dre’s legend as a producer comes from that 88’-93’ run.
Em has no message either. What is his message? I hate my baby mother and my biological mother? And I like to do an absurd amount of drugs? Em is no way shape or form represents Detroit or the culture of the D. That’s why all the Detroit rappers under 35 not named Royce 5’9” openly denounce and hate Eminem pretty much. It’s your job as a rapper to rep your city. And Marshall was never really from Motown.
If you listen closely, Em reps Warren, Michigan and the trailer park anyway. His small stint of living in Detroit, proper, if he ever lived there at all, was included in his official bio to give him hood credibility even though it’s clear Em never had any sauce or soaked up any game if he ever lived there. Rather, it’s that whole selling point of why he’s so popular with white people. He supposedly lived in the blackest city in America but stayed white.
If Eminem was black, he would be exposed for what he is... that is... a cornball from the suburbs who’s into stereotypical suburban whiteboy shyt like doing mushrooms and acid and hating his mom. He would have no fans, no accolades, no record breaking sales and streams.
Eminem is also the biggest industry plant of all time. He never wanted to rap like an edgelord 25 year old mallrat eternally going through puberty. Ironically, his best album musically speaking was Infinite where he was doing his best AZ rendition. Em was obviously coached to do the whole Slim Shady persona. Record execs saw Adam Sandler and Weird Al Yankovich going plat off of selling prepubescent toilet humor to middle schoolers and they also realized the white teeny bopper demographic was also the number one buyers of Rap music that wasn’t bootlegs back when you had to physically buy music. They intermarried those ideas with Em and have been laughing to the bank ever since. Eminem would be a footnote if it weren’t for his white skin and white privilege and legions of white fans who don’t even rock with Rap music outside of him.
Em has no message either. What is his message? I hate my baby mother and my biological mother? And I like to do an absurd amount of drugs? Em is no way shape or form represents Detroit or the culture of the D. That’s why all the Detroit rappers under 35 not named Royce 5’9” openly denounce and hate Eminem pretty much. It’s your job as a rapper to rep your city. And Marshall was never really from Motown.
If you listen closely, Em reps Warren, Michigan and the trailer park anyway. His small stint of living in Detroit, proper, if he ever lived there at all, was included in his official bio to give him hood credibility even though it’s clear Em never had any sauce or soaked up any game if he ever lived there. Rather, it’s that whole selling point of why he’s so popular with white people. He supposedly lived in the blackest city in America but stayed white.
If Eminem was black, he would be exposed for what he is... that is... a cornball from the suburbs who’s into stereotypical suburban whiteboy shyt like doing mushrooms and acid and hating his mom. He would have no fans, no accolades, no record breaking sales and streams.
Eminem is also the biggest industry plant of all time. He never wanted to rap like an edgelord 25 year old mallrat eternally going through puberty. Ironically, his best album musically speaking was Infinite where he was doing his best AZ rendition. Em was obviously coached to do the whole Slim Shady persona. Record execs saw Adam Sandler and Weird Al Yankovich going plat off of selling prepubescent toilet humor to middle schoolers and they also realized the white teeny bopper demographic was also the number one buyers of Rap music that wasn’t bootlegs back when you had to physically buy music. They intermarried those ideas with Em and have been laughing to the bank ever since. Eminem would be a footnote if it weren’t for his white skin and white privilege and legions of white fans who don’t even rock with Rap music outside of him.
The BasedFather
Task Force
I’m from Detroit and don’t fukk with Eminem. Only hyped because he’s white. Only white folks think he’s hard.
The Half-Blood FKA Prince
Avada Kedavbreh!
Top 10 #NOVELTY# rappers, his early work sure.
I’m not sure…
Dude is a great lyricist but I don’t find myself going back through his catalog like that anymore.
Anything post 2003-04 or so, outside relapse....
Thats another matter.
No. And if u got him in your top 10 i dont respect u
RARI_Godwind
St. BAWGustine - DarkSkxxxn
White Rappers, yea
"Claimin' Detroit, when y'all live twenty miles away"
"Straight outta Warren, bytch you a joke"
OperationNumbNutts
Superstar
Personally I don't have a top 10. 
But I'll say Eminem is a who's who in the game no doubt.
But I'll say Eminem is a who's who in the game no doubt.
No. Can't deny his abilities as a technician but outside of a handful of songs, the artistry is severely lacking.