I got into hip hop from puff daddy's no way out. I was young...born in 91 so obviously Eminems run was special to my generation and that plays a part.i've noticed on this site (the majority) of people that say it's a classic either got into Hip Hop through Em or in that era that say it's a classic. i don't personally see how it is, the unnecessary skits, low replay value and a lot of the subject matter is extremely dated (name dropping/dissing celebs & pop stars is always a bad idea). the rhyme schemes & technical ability shown on songs like Criminal are nothing to laugh at but i just can't fukk with the skits & joints like Drug Ballad i always thought sounded like an SSLP left over.
Regardless, that album literally has all the qualifications of a classic to me from the promotion to the classic singles to the critical reception to the commercial reception to some of the classic album cuts like I'm back (ems best song), Who Knew and Kill you. Its 100% classic even if I don't play it much anymore. That shyt had white parents and public activists acting stupid as shyt too...that show impactful it was
How yall on this site calling shyt like Good Kid Maad City classic and saying Marshall Mathers LP aint a classic. Yall fukked up man
Last edited: