Is Freddie Gibbs a legend?

Is Gibbs a legend?

  • Yes

    Votes: 14 18.4%
  • No

    Votes: 62 81.6%

  • Total voters
    76

Jaguar93

Veteran
Joined
Jan 28, 2016
Messages
22,267
Reputation
6,934
Daps
103,944
I like Gibbs but there is little to no story to tell in the grand scheme of Hip Hop regarding him.

That’s what a legend is, a story.

So when you say the word legend in the context of Hip Hop think about trying to tell a story about that person and the moment/moments they created. There has to be more there than just some albums you enjoy. There’s obviously levels to what or who is legendary but again it’s about the story.

Biz Markie was a legend…he was apart of very memorable moments. Even if it was just one big thing, if there’s a story to tell about it there is some degree of legend.

I can’t begin to reach for anything like that for Freddie despite how dope he can be, it’s not just about quality of music. shyt Vanilla Ice is for sure a legend off one sing you dig?

His association with Jeezy is probably the most notable thing about his career that creates some kind of narrative.
:ehh:I actually agree well said
 

Tommy Sheppard

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
17,268
Reputation
1,898
Daps
51,217
Reppin
NULL
I like Gibbs but there is little to no story to tell in the grand scheme of Hip Hop regarding him.

That’s what a legend is, a story.

So when you say the word legend in the context of Hip Hop think about trying to tell a story about that person and the moment/moments they created. There has to be more there than just some albums you enjoy. There’s obviously levels to what or who is legendary but again it’s about the story.

Biz Markie was a legend…he was apart of very memorable moments. Even if it was just one big thing, if there’s a story to tell about it there is some degree of legend.

I can’t begin to reach for anything like that for Freddie despite how dope he can be, it’s not just about quality of music. shyt Vanilla Ice is for sure a legend off one sing you dig?

His association with Jeezy is probably the most notable thing about his career that creates some kind of narrative.
This is spot on.
 

tuckgod

The high exalted
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
53,770
Reputation
16,053
Daps
191,463
Now this is too far in the opposite direction...
If Puffy wasn’t letting Clive Davis plug him Big would be Rock from Heltah Skeltah.

Hip hop history was determined by who was allowing Jews to fukk them.

I’ll just stick to the actual music.
 

Figaro

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2014
Messages
7,099
Reputation
2,759
Daps
28,016
Reppin
The 36 Chambers
Dope rapper, even though his subject matter is very limited majority of the times.

His LP's with Madlib have good replay value & are incredible albums.

His other LP's are great when they first drop but I never really find myself going back to them apart from a handful of tracks :yeshrug:
 

Long Live The Kane

Tyrant Titan
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
17,287
Reputation
5,009
Daps
64,973
He's a Gary legend but that's far as it goes:mjlol:

Even this is in question. I’m almost certain I’m first person to ever mention bruh name in the SOHH/Coli shared universe back in like ‘04 or some shyt back when he first got signed to interscope and was telling my homies in college he was bout to get signed to G-Unit…but he ain’t never popped like that in the G…make what you will of a street rapper that never had their hometown on lock, but Gibbs’ come up was purely some internet shyt

I’d give him “blog-rap era legend” (id have to put some thought into where he stood in the ranks of dudes like Spitta, Krit, Wiz, etc) before “Gary Legend” (dudes yall never heard of like Ric Jilla or the Grind Family are more revered on some beloved Gary Hood Legend shyt)
 
Last edited:

Higher Tech

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
15,000
Reputation
2,380
Daps
39,541
Reppin
Gary, Indiana
Even this is in question. I’m almost certain I’m first person to ever mention bruh name in the SOHH/Coli shared universe back in like ‘04 or some shyt back when he first got signed to interscope and was telling my homies in college he was bout to get signed to G-Unit…but he ain’t never popped like that in the G…make what you will of a street rapper that never had their hometown on lock, but Gibbs’ come up was purely some internet shyt

I’d give him “blog-rap era legend” (id have to put some thought into where he stood in the ranks of dudes like Spitta, Krit, Wiz, etc) before “Gary Legend” (dudes yall never heard of like Ric Jilla or the Grind Family are more revered on some beloved Gary Hood Legend shyt)
He was one of the guys here, everybody knew him. He ran with a crew and he was lower level in terms of popularity but his skills were definitely acknowledged. He really had to grind to get where he is. He has some folks here that don't like him. He's burned some bridges (from my understanding it's not really his fault) but most people in my age range really rock with his music. He came back and gave all the kids at the high school backpacks and shoes one year when he had something with Adidas. We can pick and choose what words define him, but he's respected as a brotha that's done well for himself from Gary and never really forgot about the hometown.

Ric Jill and the Grind and CCA all came before Fred. The really pioneered rapping in the area.
 

Mac Ten

Class of 97 !!!
Joined
Dec 15, 2019
Messages
11,351
Reputation
5,459
Daps
20,773
Reppin
B-More
Nah...

Him leaving Jeezy was the best thing that ever happened to him though. He could have handled that amicably as well.

Gibbs being a emotional diva kinda makes me not wanna listen to his music.

Plus, I didn't like how did Curren$y either.

Nikkas get to tweeting online when they're mad.
 

maxamusa

Veteran
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
31,812
Reputation
9,467
Daps
82,039
Reppin
Old York
Nah...

Him leaving Jeezy was the best thing that ever happened to him though. He could have handled that amicably as well.

Gibbs being a emotional diva kinda makes me not wanna listen to his music.

Plus, I didn't like how did Curren$y either.

Nikkas get to tweeting online when they're mad.

no weapon formed against jet lyfe shall prosper :ohlawd:
 

bordeaux

xxx
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
7,876
Reputation
865
Daps
17,001
Reppin
God's Plan
i mean, his catalog is very strong. ill say this, if dude had died violently directly after his last album i wouldnt be surprised to see it being thrown around.
 

Mac Ten

Class of 97 !!!
Joined
Dec 15, 2019
Messages
11,351
Reputation
5,459
Daps
20,773
Reppin
B-More
no weapon formed against jet lyfe shall prosper :ohlawd:

Hell nah...

Spitta ain't out here kicking fake gangsta bars nor is he stunting on folks. He makes that chill, laid back music that could really take its effects when you're smoking a big ol blunt.
 
Top