Is Ginobili top 10 SG of all time?

[SuaveHooper88]

yes he is

 

[malbaker86]

Threads like this is why i LOVE the Coli. Both sides made great points

 

[Supreme365]

mj, kobe, wade, clyde drexler, oscar robertson, ray allen, george gervin, pistol pete, mitch richmond, allen iverson, reggie miller, tmac, vince carter

ginobili might not crack top 20.

You don't consider the big O a point guard and do you consider Jerry west a 2

 

[Supreme365]

The list of elite SG with 4+ chips is pretty short

The list of shooting guards who played with Duncan is even shorter

 

[ManBearPig]

nah

maybe top 15

 

[Da King]

The list of shooting guards who played with Duncan is even shorter

His gold medal run, 4 chips, all star >>>

 

[nieman]

Manu is Top 10-15 based on talent...because he is unguardable but not on what he actually accomplished on the court. I say it all the time, he's the Sheed of SGs. So, he's really an underachiever.

I'm also taking Mike Finley over him. Hell, he's lucky if I don't take H20, Spree, Michael Redd, Monta, Kev-Mart, Jimmy Jax over him. They've all had better primes/peaks. That's the crop he belongs with.

 

[Mr210]

Top 20 but not top 10

 

[AFRAM GLORY]

No but his influence to the game should exceed his all time ranking. The euro step, crafty european style of play james harden and todays players use that's all manu right there.

 

[#SOG_soldier]

Hell no



Wade
T mac
Mj
Devin booker
George gervin
Big o
Tobe
Devin booker
Dr j
Joe dumas
Tim Hardaway Sr
Devin booker
Earl Monroe
Allen Iverson
Ray allen

 

[#SOG_soldier]

Even Manu looking away in disgust at this question

The spurs

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

yes he is

@Raul = @SuaveHooper88.

 

[SuaveHooper88]

Manu is Top 10-15 based on talent...because he is unguardable but not on what he actually accomplished on the court. I say it all the time, he's the Sheed of SGs. So, he's really an underachiever.

I'm also taking Mike Finley over him. Hell, he's lucky if I don't take H20, Spree, Michael Redd, Monta, Kev-Mart, Jimmy Jax over him. They've all had better primes/peaks. That's the crop he belongs with.

You cant be serious. Manu Ginobli was ARGUABLY the best Shooting Guard in the league for a few seasons.

And was arguably the spurs Second best or BEST player for a lot of playoff series during the years they won championships. And the years they didn't.

You just exposed yourselfaas a casual

 

[Remote]

@Raul = @SuaveHooper88.

 

[LeMAO]

Manu is Top 10-15 based on talent...because he is unguardable but not on what he actually accomplished on the court. I say it all the time, he's the Sheed of SGs. So, he's really an underachiever.

I'm also taking Mike Finley over him. Hell, he's lucky if I don't take H20, Spree, Michael Redd, Monta, Kev-Mart, Jimmy Jax over him. They've all had better primes/peaks. That's the crop he belongs with.