Is it racist to require immigrants in an English speaking country to learn English?

[Turk]

the prime minister of England posted this and the responses have been mostly angry ones. Lots of claims of racism, fascism, etc but I dont see it that way. If you move to another country and you dont know the language you should learn the language. If i moved to France I would try my best to learn French

 

[bnew]

these people are responsible for the deaths of hundreds if not thousands of languages cause they wanted people to speak english.

 

[bourgeoisie tall freak]

there's people who are mute and can still live in any society so this seems arbitrary

 

[Neuromancer]

No. How are you going to communicate with the rest of the local populace? This is what people complain Americans do in other countries. So why is it ok when other people are asked to do it?

 

[horizon]

there's people who are mute and can still live in any society so this seems arbitrary

Good point

 

[Lord-Yosh]

Any country you move to and decide to stay you should try and learn the language unless you're just lazy

 

[bourgeoisie tall freak]

Good point

thank you. and now that i think about it there's people that weren't raised with manners that will also not speak when spoken to and they are free to live as well
nobody is forced to communicate in any type of way so it doesn't make sense to require a specific language as a matter of law

 

[UpAndComing]

Montreal, Canada has a French Language requirement. If you do not speak French, you are relegated to tourist and minimum wage jobs. To work a high level job, you have to speak fluent French

This is how it should be done. Don't "force" people to learn English. Just reward people monetarily who are fluent in English

Honestly, that's how it should be

 

[badboys11]

How can u read the traffic signs if u can't read English?


I'm planning a trip to Europe and a part of the preparation is picking up local languages just in case....not to mention what if I want to speak to someone?


Seems racist to move to a country and not even try to learn the language, tf u move here for?


More importantly, it shows ignorance and stupidity if your unable to learn the local language. Are u too slow to learn?

 

[Henny and_ HotWings]

fukk no it ain’t racist… how much mercy do you think one of our black asses would get if we moved to a non English speaking country? You think they’re gonna make special accommodations for us!? Naw , gonna gonna have to get with the program or be shyt outta luck

 

[AnonymityX1000]

Montreal, Canada has a French Language requirement. If you do not speak French, you are regulated to tourist and minimum wage jobs. To work a high level job, you have to speak fluent French

This is how it should be done. Don't "force" people to learn English. Just reward people monetarily who are fluent in English

Honestly, that's how it should be

I agree encourage it but it shouldn't be a requirement to love somewhere.
These white boys would be beside themselves if they were told to learn a language of a country they moved to.

 

[315]

Why wouldn't you learn the language of the country you live in?
Americans get shyt for not knowing other languages in America lol

 

[Wig Twistin Season]

Here’s the easy answer, what language is taught as the primary language in that country’s schools?

What language is their constitution written in?

What language is on their currency that isn’t a dead language?

What primary language are contracts written in?

Etc.

 

[Devilinurear]

the prime minister of England posted this and the responses have been mostly angry ones. Lots of claims of racism, fascism, etc but I dont see it that way. If you move to another country and you dont know the language you should learn the language. If i moved to France I would try my best to learn French

It would be better for you to learn because it would make it easier to move around but it shouldn't be a requirement. You know how easy it is be taken advantage of if you don't know the language.

 

[Amo Husserl]

there's people who are mute and can still live in any society so this seems arbitrary

Comparatively, how many mute people are there in a county... like the UK(?)... compared to their speaking counterparts?