Majestic Pape
The-Coli = W SOHH = L
You can't have Stockton ahead of Isiah.
Is Jason Kidd a top 3 PG of all time?
- Thread starter Heelmatic
- Start date
You can't have Stockton ahead of Isiah.
malbaker86
Gators
What makes Kidd better than The Glove tho?
The "disrespect" Payton's career has gotten is ridiculous. Well maybe not disrespect.....it's just like people forget he even existed when talmbout the top PG's of all time.
Big Mel
@bigboss
it's between Kidd or Stockton for the 4th slot.
Magic, Oscar & Zeek have the top 3 locked even though I never saw the Big O.
the 5th slot is interesting. I think it goes to an active player.
Magic, Oscar & Zeek have the top 3 locked even though I never saw the Big O.
the 5th slot is interesting. I think it goes to an active player.
Im talking As a first option(which is why i said offensive anchor)Kidd would make a great number 3. Plus those nets teams were always mediocre to crap offensively.
Kidd simply doesn't compare to alot of PG's offensively particulary as scorers
cornercommission2k12
so this were u dudes went
i think he getting a little overhyped due to him retiring
my top 5
magic
isaiah
oscar
gary payton
then kidd for me
if iverson is considered a pg, then i got him above kidd and payton.
my top 5
magic
isaiah
oscar
gary payton
then kidd for me
if iverson is considered a pg, then i got him above kidd and payton.
My neck and my back
All Star
did i just read that gp was a combo guard? 
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
GP was never really a PG like the rest of the guys in the top 5.
He was somewhat of a combo guard...Picture a less explosive Westbrook.
His best years('99-'02) came during the Westphal era in Seattle.They played that run & gun style and Payton had the best spurt of his career.Ironically, the Sonics sucked ass during that strecth.GP was never one to make his team mates elevate their game.Stats really don't tell the whole story.Looking at stats, you'd think Marbury made his teammates better, to
Payton was more of a scoring pg....had a ugly ass, knuckle ball J, and a decent post game because of his size.His offense was ugly, but effective.
He averaged 16 points and 6.7 APG for his career.Iverson, who's always getting ragged on for being a ball hog, averaged 6.2 APG for his career.
I'd definitely take Kidd over Payton.Kidd carried a bunch of scrubs to the NBA finals.Not only scrubs, but a franchise that had a culture of losing and was unaccustomed to success.He lifted that whole franchise up.
What did Payton do? what is he remembered for besides a cool nickname? Where's his all time NBA great moments/ defining moments? When Payton had the Sonics all to himself, they were mediocre as shyt.
Kevin Johnson was definitely better.....And I'm contemplating taking Tim Hardaway over him, to
Top 10 WOAT post in Coliseum history
Sent from my HTC Wildfire S using Tapatalk 2
Carlos Huerta
Just keep my rep red
but that's not his main job. Magic is the greatest PG of all time and his career ppg doesn't even break 20.
King P
Legends Never Die
GP was never really a PG like the rest of the guys in the top 5.
He was somewhat of a combo guard...Picture a less explosive Westbrook.
His best years('99-'02) came during the Westphal era in Seattle.They played that run & gun style and Payton had the best spurt of his career.Ironically, the Sonics sucked ass during that strecth.GP was never one to make his team mates elevate their game.Stats really don't tell the whole story.Looking at stats, you'd think Marbury made his teammates better, to
Payton was more of a scoring pg....had a ugly ass, knuckle ball J, and a decent post game because of his size.His offense was ugly, but effective.
He averaged 16 points and 6.7 APG for his career.Iverson, who's always getting ragged on for being a ball hog, averaged 6.2 APG for his career.
I'd definitely take Kidd over Payton.Kidd carried a bunch of scrubs to the NBA finals.Not only scrubs, but a franchise that had a culture of losing and was unaccustomed to success.He lifted that whole franchise up.
What did Payton do? what is he remembered for besides a cool nickname? Where's his all time NBA great moments/ defining moments? When Payton had the Sonics all to himself, they were mediocre as shyt.
Kevin Johnson was definitely better.....And I'm contemplating taking Tim Hardaway over him, to
What in the blue hell did I just read?
Carlos Huerta
Just keep my rep red
What in the blue hell did I just read?
Kevin Johnson was better than Gary Payton.
MooseMouthMthafuga
Veteran
You gassed up off GP, he was never really that nice.
Go ahead...break it down....tell me where I'm wrong?
Why do you think GP is better than Kidd and Kevin Johnson?
I watched GP his whole career....Cool nickname....swag....but I'm telling you, Kidd and KJ were better.He's nowhere in the discussion for top 5 pg of all time.
As far a true PG skills..."court vision..passing..making shyt easier for his teammates" he's middle of the pack.He was never a big game/ clutch player, neither
I know...I
.....nikkaz love them some GP....I understand that.He's one of the realest cats to lace em up in the NBA......As far as talent, I think he's overrated out there.But that's just my opinion
AlbertPullhoez
The Takeover
You gassed up off GP, he was never really that nice.
Go ahead...break it down....tell me where I'm wrong?
Why do you think GP is better than Kidd and Kevin Johnson?
I watched GP his whole career....Cool nickname....swag....but I'm telling you, Kidd and KJ were better.He's nowhere in the discussion for top 5 pg of all time.
As far a true PG skills..."court vision..passing..making shyt easier for his teammates" he's middle of the pack.He was never a big game/ clutch player, neither
I know...I
GP one of the best two-way guards in NBA history. nikkas talking about Kevin Johnson like Payton didn't lock him up in the 93 WCF. Let's also not forget he was the leader of a perennial title contender with the 90's Sonics.
GP was a problem on both ends he could score and lock down the other team's best scorer. Only point guard to ever win DPOY and he's overrated? fukk outta here
Sent from my HTC Wildfire S using Tapatalk 2
Mic-Nificent
I didn't eat nobody
I swear I never seen another situation where a players actions as a GM and coach so graetly affected how people saw him as a player.
Isiah's legacy just hasn't been the same since his dealings with the Knicks.....
Isiah's legacy just hasn't been the same since his dealings with the Knicks.....
