Is Lost Tapes superior to Illmatic?

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
66,279
Reputation
10,729
Daps
221,847
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
Lost tapes got one listen from me. I think it was a pure gimmick but we live in a capitalistic society geared to make a buck.
:what: some of u nikkas suffer from mental illness. And it’s not crazy to prefer Lost Tapes over Illmatic. I know ALOT of people who will throw in Lost Tapes WAY faster than Illmatic.
 

BulletProof

Just a B@stard Living in a Suit
Joined
Dec 22, 2013
Messages
7,349
Reputation
1,100
Daps
12,314
Reppin
Neck ties and boxing gloves.
I mean Purple is probably a top 5 Nas track for me and U Gotta Love It is also classic, but :patrice: . I'd say It Was Written is the better argument here.

Also fukk Gnoz for refusing to acknowledge It Was Written on its anniversaries :pacspit: and continuing to do the same ol played out fukking illatic concert every year :pacspit: . fukk you Gnoz acknowledge one of the GOAT albums at the pinnacle of rap :damn:

I would imagine that album has a lot of baggage for all kinds of reasons.

It's one of my favorites but I can understand if that album may have some energy that's a little heavy and Nas seems to be really enjoying life right now.

Rightfully so.
 

Scientific Playa

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Oct 13, 2013
Messages
13,930
Reputation
3,310
Daps
24,906
Reppin
Championships
Some of y’all just be saying anything :mjlol:

we all have our own taste.
since y'all know i'm the coli grandad :laugh: let me put u up on some deep ish that nobody can f with on here concerning having an ear for music.
my mom heard me bumping this legend's first hit on repeat and she took me to go see him at a concert in the BX.
yeah, I took the photo. 😉

fWsn7UAI_hxky6m-_sSVk6WxKnM448VEIVVJWXqedAsNyoPh6IRGQjqi0sFux-8JlWmZzVFuvNGDpsXg2mGF5XKmkR9b4RjewxxnIGMh9EGuSDkcvIz81vb7hCfEWNW43GpsPhyk3WXvyk6plYv5KxZ3yhOKjTYwMkw3rd0vtUCS-jIPkYMl4J0jqw1PNIIJPtoa-iA0a54aKkOgYhxESUfZE4lltKVCnVsF93JuMNji3SaOYz42geH2IgZsQ6mrgEoZATB3N3xVxOif0xQvTC1DAo5hb4JFrQtvfYduYYb23rwCQdkEP4CyJjCl-LhrjMk4bjlsKiUu5NKF848EuEYch_k431GtbKOtSDmLZveLF4L2JsyfwuUsOyZ9_CFlsRNSkRLvOowdX5Pqh_M4JJIl9_flU4jDcBgM65UaUu2i22yFhlA_URkqZx18KMYgYkY3u5kbVH70w9Hm6ivAXYI0NnlogVz68fwl87X1YYxKOaPKOwaAizdydQROOoxtqNeBlHkAfG8_XxEAIpQ-781Ug0oAuyTGGhygwRo3qMlxElsNE_hT4W5m8qj6UyjhfTX5eo31DF9hlyvNAxaAPziGs60VawOXcQiM5mK8x8YnZeB8i_djnTCK0IxZPjHZFmEjVl5Lz3kY2VX2aJW1XT8D4HZzytvez0hRBlaqbTekmzHezygmBR-1yeqY8AErlhbh3-yqjzgFsCr1sfCEloM8_9-d8z-L_kLbv0TtDDzPs1oYdktfqwKiaGcVxwfubs_d62by6CIPfOINGAFLbnCeDCydQtitgKjkPEd9JiXvNDfCFct7QB32d45CqlTKBn-YAtDPKAjrUvN9EHw0JAyi0m-3n1JAhZ62zmRXboJSyNQaQcvjgNEart2iV3Ks1Gr8kVNl4Ie6AyzzS-_Ai6-8Pi6q06y2nlz_cP8UyMj5nN4YX3PPj0ogOU-jDEY3P16tIVK1CrPNCpbaViSaQA=w862-h938-s-no
 

RennisDeynolds

I am untethered and my rage knows no bounds!
Joined
Feb 2, 2017
Messages
42,973
Reputation
7,865
Daps
125,008
Reppin
Paddys Pub
I would imagine that album has a lot of baggage for all kinds of reasons.

It's one of my favorites but I can understand if that album may have some energy that's a little heavy and Nas seems to be really enjoying life right now.

Rightfully so.


Here yall go defending Gnoz :camby: . One of the GOAT albums deserve praise by its architect :pacspit:


His lazy ass just can't be bothered to remember anything beyond the 10 songs on illMatic :comeon:
 

Long Live The Kane

Tyrant Titan
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
17,211
Reputation
4,970
Daps
64,698
I was a way bigger fan of Nas when lost tapes dropped…I enjoyed it in real time, whereas illmatic was something I had to double back on and revisit afterwards …though It Ain’t Hard to Tell might be the first song I’d play if aliens landed in my backyard and told me “play the consummate hip hop song”
 

Braman

Veteran
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
16,800
Reputation
3,998
Daps
66,492
Not crazy at all. Really depends on how you grade

Illmatic is only 9 songs. Imo 1 weak song (relative to the others), Halftime

Lost Tapes is 12 songs with 2 weak songs (relative to others), Everybody’s Crazy and Drunk By Myself

So illmatic is the more flawless album, but there may be better, more potent songs on Lost tapes

Also your age and when/how you were exposed to both albums matter. I’m old af and even I was only 12 when Illmatic dropped. So most of my experience with it came after the fact. Whereas Lost Tapes dropped in my musical prime I was like 21. I was able to experience it in real time.

So for me Lost Tapes is the one. If you count it as an album it’s the greatest album of all time in my book
 
Top