Is Mace Windu and Yoda to blame for Anakin turning to the dark side?

[bammtronics]

If Darth Vader didn’t exist, Darth Sidious wouldn’t have been killed.

Related: The new Star Wars movies killed the franchise. I haven’t seen Solo yet and don’t have an interest.

Why the fukk would the Empire be destroyed and then the First Order takes its place. Why bring back original characters just to kill them? Why introduce Ray if she’s not related to the Skywalkers? They’re really fukking up the franchise. It’s DCEU levels of bad.

- It’s not that bad. They stretching yeah, but DC bad?

- Empire had a lot of resources and people outside of the Death Star and they still had beef. The battlefront game alludes to this

- I’m not buying that Rey isn’t a skywalker yet. Kylo sounded like he was BSing when he told her that

 

[bammtronics]

But Luke started at an even older age

Yeah but after “balance” had been restored, and solely by Yoda. Not the same as when they were churning out Baby Jedi from their factory

 

[Brolic Scholar]

- It’s not that bad. They stretching yeah, but DC bad?

- Empire had a lot of resources and people outside of the Death Star and they still had beef. The battlefront game alludes to this

- I’m not buying that Rey isn’t a skywalker yet. Kylo sounded like he was BSing when he told her that

It’s close...

 

[Isaiah Bradley]

Using him to spy on Sideous was the stupidest decision ever made. I put that on Mace.

nah, Mace and the council needed concrete proof before accusing a chancellor of misdoings, no proof then it would've been treason. At that point all the chancellor would've needed to do was to convince the senate to forbid the Jedi religion throughout the galaxy for treason

Not them specifically but the Jedi as a whole. Even on the precipice, Anakin was the only one willing to do what was right. Even if that meant turning on his friend. Realizing that he was the only one doing what the Jedi were supposed to do, he saw he was the only one that would suffer. The Jedi were egotistical. That's why Yoda said they failed him instead of the other way around right?

which was?

If Darth Vader didn’t exist, Darth Sidious wouldn’t have been killed.

Related: The new Star Wars movies killed the franchise. I haven’t seen Solo yet and don’t have an interest.

Why the fukk would the Empire be destroyed and then the First Order takes its place. Why bring back original characters just to kill them? Why introduce Ray if she’s not related to the Skywalkers? They’re really fukking up the franchise. It’s DCEU levels of bad.

facts. I abandon this franchise the moment they made Rey defeat a trained Jedi. I knew I made the right decision when my brother called me from his car outside the theater pissed off about General Leia flying through fawking space. No Jedi masters or Sith lords have that ability, but she does? pandering and checklisting

 

[semicko82]

Anakin fell to the dark side because of bad writing.

 

[Formerly Black Trash]

If Darth Vader didn’t exist, Darth Sidious wouldn’t have been killed.

Related: The new Star Wars movies killed the franchise. I haven’t seen Solo yet and don’t have an interest.

Why the fukk would the Empire be destroyed and then the First Order takes its place. Why bring back original characters just to kill them? Why introduce Ray if she’s not related to the Skywalkers? They’re really fukking up the franchise. It’s DCEU levels of bad.

It’s very sad to see that nothing changed after the OG characters wins
Probably realistic tho
World is always a shyt hole

 

[FSP]

It was a wrap when his mom died

 

[semicko82]

While watching those movies I never felt like Anakin was a tragic hero and his flaws were put on blast. It was inevitable he was going to the dark side.

 

[Lord_nikon]

Anakin was already a borderline narcissus, self centered, megalomaniacal and simp, nevertheless he had more of a reason to join the dark side (unlike that bytch made kylo ren.)

 

[Clayton Endicott]

No.

It was Qui-Gon Jinns fault

Anakin was too old to start training

If the Jedi didn't get him first, Sidious would have gotten to him. It would have been too damn risky to let someone with all that unchecked power roam the galaxy.

 

[bammtronics]

If the Jedi didn't get him first, Sidious would have gotten to him. It would have been too damn risky to let someone with all that unchecked power roam the galaxy.

And yet they still brought him right to Palpatine

 

[8WON6]

Star Wars needs to stop making the same movie over and over. A group of fighters coming together to face the darkside. Somebody gone be in them fighter jets. *yawn* Then we get minimal hand-to-hand combat with the lightsabers and force telekinesis powers. They need to make some movies that are grittier with like a action spy thriller Bourne Supremacy type of shyt, but with lightsabers and people using the force in close quarters combat. They keep trying to make these sweeping epics that are all the same movie.

 

[BaltimoreTwilightMarauder]

The Jedi order was to blame for its parroting of sith-like regressive rhetoric. Theres a reason why in episode 3 both the emperor and Mace Windu say the line "hes too dangerous to be left alive". George Lucas knew what he was doing.

The two extremes of the force(light and dark) shared dark parellels...including a lack of nuiance and dogmatic strict religions. Hence "he's too dangerous to be left alive". These parallels led to the Jedi collapse.

End Thread.

 

[BaldingSoHard]

No.

It was Qui-Gon Jinns fault

Anakin was too old to start training

What does that even mean? Breh was like 7. How old is too old?

 

[Spiritual Stratocaster]

Anakin was too old..they expected him not to have emotional attachments