Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?

[Chip Skylark]

Im very confident mahomes will end up top 3 breh.

But he aint brady yet. At least not yet.

My top 3

1. Brady



2a. Manning
2b. Montana


You gotta do more than putting up stats to pass manning and montana. You gotta dominate for 10+ years.

You gotta do unthinkable to pass brady. He gotta do the shyt he do in the SB. Remember brady beat mahomes twice in the playoffs. Took another team to SB.

And most importantly 35 playoff wins. Winning is everything for QB. Gotta win and dominate for 2 decades and consistently win. Just look at how quickly narrative changed for Rodgers. Mvps don't mean shyt. Pretty stats dont mean shyt.

Brady is Mt. Everest.
Mahomes right now aint even Mt. Rainier.

Your eye test don't mean shyt either.

Oh no check my stats i've never said he's brady. 7 rings man that's kind of tough but he's definitley one of the greats. If Pat gets 3 rings then I'll make that argument

 

[Braman]

In 1-6 years there will be another quarterback who will enter this league and cats will do the shyt, "my God we've never seen a player this talented before".

Exactly. They couldn’t even help themself with Joe Burrow. I fw The Get up but they really said ‘Mahomes is the most talented, but Joe burrow is the best at playing the QB position’ Like wtf does that even mean.

It doesn’t matter. When it’s all said n done whoever got more rings while being elite is gonna be the best.

And just wait til the eagles beat KC

‘Guys I know Mahomes is the most talented, burrow is the best at playing the QB position, but Jalen Hurts is the best weapon at QB. We haven’t seen anything like this’

 

[Flight]

Wait are you talking about the superbowl where Mahomes was hitting nikkas on their chest and they kept dropping everything. That superbowl despite having the worst O-lkmenin history Mahomes even had the Bucks sideline in awe of his performance. That superbowl?

Had em amazed…

 

[FabTrey]

Oh no check my stats i've never said he's brady. 7 rings man that's kind of tough but he's definitley one of the greats. If Pat gets 3 rings then I'll make that argument

Brady is 7-3 in SB. 10 SB appearances. 3 rings? that's cute. Let's not forget, Brady could've gone to 2 more SBs in 2006 and 2021. don't forget we were robbed of Brady's absolute peak in 2008 with an injury.

Road to being top 5 is very simple. keep dominating and win a SB or two. He will get there.

but road to being the GOAT? almost impossible.


and no matter what happens, brady can still claim he beat mahomes twice in the playoffs.

 

[Biscayne]

Let's leave the goat alone. He stands alone undisputed.

But let's not forget Rodgers.

Only difference between Rodgers and Mahomes is that Mahomes is a better teammate and he isn't afraid to make mistakes. Not to mention he had better better weapons, defense and coaching. And that translates to more wins and more SB appearances.

As far as the pure arm talent goes, i give a slight edge to prime Rodgers.

I give Mahomes the edge in escabi
No he is the Lebron of football after the Eagles dog walk these dudes he will have a losing super bowl record always remember he may have the greatest offensive coach of All Time.

Slow ya'll roll!

Looking at Mahomes post season stats in the super bowl era, I’d put him ahead of Rodgers. And just about anyone not named Montana and Brady. Maybe Peyton. No need to slow anything. In 6 seasons, he’s had some of the greatest post season runs(statistically) in NFL history.

 

[Gator48]

No... he doesn't have to worry about Reggie White or LT DDTing him 3 seconds after the ball is released

 

[Chip Skylark]

Brady is 7-3 in SB. 10 SB appearances. 3 rings? that's cute. Let's not forget, Brady could've gone to 2 more SBs in 2006 and 2021. don't forget we were robbed of Brady's absolute peak in 2008 with an injury.

Road to being top 5 is very simple. keep dominating and win a SB or two. He will get there.

but road to being the GOAT? almost impossible.


and no matter what happens, brady can still claim he beat mahomes twice in the playoffs.

Bro you keep talking about Brady when I said I’ve never compared Pat to him.

If you want an excuse to bring him up then use somebody else. Cut it out man

 

[prime]

He will be the GOAT if he continues on this trajectory.

He'll never get close to 7 rings obviously but his playing level and ability is far above Brady's and that will be considered in such debates a decade from now.

Yep I was saying this exact same thing at the barber shop last week

 

[The Devil's Advocate]

He will be the GOAT if he continues on this trajectory.

He'll never get close to 7 rings obviously but his playing level and ability is far above Brady's and that will be considered in such debates a decade from now.

Why can't he get to 7?

Brady won 3 in his first 5 years... Didn't win the 4th until his 15th year...

If Pat wins that'll be 2 in 6.. and he'll have 9 more years to win 2 more... At this pace, this man bout to be in at least half of those SB's.....

 

[Stone]

He’s already probably had the best 5 year start we’ve ever seen looking at numbers and accolades.

A lot is riding on this game though, if he doesn’t have a good game and they lose he’s probably put on a completely different trajectory.

But if he balls and they win alot of people’s faves will be in trouble

 

[iceberg_is_on_fire]

Had em amazed…

I don't think I'll ever be more amazed at a football play than the one he threw laying sideways in the air. He threw a dot that hit his receiver in the helmet, after going through the hands. Mahomes was clearly the best player on the field that day.

I hate prematurely claiming someone to be the best anything, especially so young. In this very forum, I've said Aaron Rodgers might have been but no, as great as he was, he's not this. Nobody's ever been this. I think Mahomes is now, he's going to make it damn near unanimous among the remainder of the non-believers when he is done and hangs up the cleats.

 

[JYoung24]

Brady and Manning are tier 1 when it comes to being the most cerebral QB. Brady became better simply because Brady doesn't overthink like Manning and played better against tougher D. Seattle SB is a classic example. How Brady neutralized their weaknesses was a master class. Manning's biggest downfall is that he was too smart for his own good.

I got nothing but respect for manning, but saying brady isn't up there with manning when it comes to reading the D is so 2009.

Rodgers is 3-4 tier below brady/manning. Rodgers ad libs way too much.

Brady went up an injured the legion of doom before that he was looking trash against them too

 

[JYoung24]

It's definitely still Brady. He also has shown us that QB isn't a position that is even really about physical ability or talent, it's all mental and intangibles.

In terms of pure arm talent Mahomes isn't the most talented either. It's Aaron Rodgers.

Mahomes with 3 is definitely the conversation starter, but as of now not yet.

Brady overrated as shyt he gets too much credit he don't deserve

 

[JYoung24]

My only knock on Rodgers is unlike Pat and Brady who fight for their teams with not only their talent but their hunger to win and leadership he’ll bytch and throw you under the bus

Thats a myth about Rodger Rodgers want to win just as bad
T

 

[JYoung24]

He’s better than Rodgers. Rodgers stay underachieving. He’s only been to 1 SB all those years……….

He had better teams than Rodgers but he's definitely better then brady