Is red dead redemption 2 the greatest game ever

[BobbyBooshay]

Up there with MGS, GTA SA

 

[419scam]

Most overrated game imo. Gameplay is a joke. Very poor

 

[El Poyo Loco]

Spoiler

When you're on Arthur last mission and the music is playing you know he's going to die then when you're John Marston and you cant wait for revenge on Micah

 

[DaRealness]

I swear Rockstar must have IGN in their pockets....every game is rated a 10/10.

shyt doesn't interest me at all...I couldn't even get into the first game too tough so I ended up selling it in the end.

I need more than good graphics to keep me hooked.

 

[YOGEBEAR09]

I swear Rockstar must have IGN in their pockets....every game is rated a 10/10.

shyt doesn't interest me at all...I couldn't even get into the first game too tough so I ended up selling it in the end.

I need more than good graphics to keep me hooked.

nikka did you just say you viukdnt get into the first game because it was too tough nikka just sell your console

 

[CarbonBraddock]

The greatest game ever made is the Elder Scrolls: Morrowind. All of you casuals disgust me.

 

[samtalksradio]

Nah GOW (2018) is better and is the Game of the year, so it's not even the best now, much less of all time, so no.

 

[NotAnFBIagent]

Nah. It's a game whose gorgeous visuals are overshadowed by outdated mechanics that remove player agency, confining the player within a very rigid set of rules that makes for an unbearably linear experience. After Witcher 3, where missions had multiple ways to be completed and the story adapted to choices made in even seemingly unrelated side quests, RDR2 was a disappointing step back for the open world genre. Unless they return to the drawing board and introduce a radical shift in the design of their games, I'm done with Rockstar. Even the shallowness of Spiderman made for an outing that towered over the mediocrity of RDR2.

This guy

 

[Duke Dixon]

I really enjoy the game but I can't say its the greatest.

There are a lot of annoying things in the game but I still have a lot of fun. I hope online is good and fixes some of the issues.

 

[I Really Mean It]

This guy

Game is an overrated slog that happens to provide unprecedented visual fidelity for an open world offering, an admitted plus that does nothing to remove the burden of its many shortcomings.

 

[NotAnFBIagent]

Game is an overrated slog that happens to provide unprecedented visual fidelity for an open world offering, an admitted plus that does nothing to remove the burden of its many shortcomings.

You got a masters in game critique?

 

[kevm3]

not to me. best graphics, decent story, but the actual controls are really bad

 

[Cryptocurrency Scarface]

nikka said all Arkhams like Origins and Knight don't exist

Also the camera is a forced inclusion

Arkham origins was piff i beat that on Wii U

because we had no games

that deathstroke boss battle was GOAT level especially on Hard with no hints

 

[Crayola Coyote]

Wait until they get online multiplayer


Its gon be alot of white boys on that shyt playin as the klan

Does the game play like GTA?

 

[I Really Mean It]

You got a masters in game critique?

No, I just play a hell of a lot of games, and I know an overrated chore when I've spent at least ten hours playing one. Game is pretty, but tediously boring.