lets break this down scientifically:
Tier 1 ("Superstars")
C - Dwight (superstar, top 4-5 player in the L)
SG - Kobe (superstar, top 7-8 player in the L)
advantage - Dwight is more dominant and younger
Tier 2 ("Should be a superstar, but injuries and general bytchassness limits them")
C - Bynum (star, avgs 19pts 12reb, young but knee issues)
SG - Wade (star, avgs 22pts, 5reb, 4asst, 30yrs old with knee issues)
advantage - draw (both are diva-bytches, with knee issues and star play)
Tier 3 ("Unnecessary Max Contract Guys")
C- Hibbert (all star, 13pts, 9reb, 2blcks )
Chandler (starter, DPOY, 11, 10, 1.5blks)
SG -
J. Johnson (all star, 19pts, 3reb, 4ast)
Ginobili (all star, 13pts, 3reb, 4ast)
Harden (6th man of the yr, 17pts, 4reb, 4ast)
Gordon (starter, 20pts, 3reb, 3ast)
advantage - SGs, overpaid but more productive than the Cs
Tier 4 ("Useful, but flawed")
Cs
Gasol (starter, 15, 9, 1.5blks )
Cousins (starter, future all star, 18pts, 11reb)
Bogut (starter, broken, 11pts, 8reb, 2blks)
McGee (retard, 11pts, 8reb, 2.2blks)
SG
K. Martin (starter, 17pts, nothing else)
Ray Allen
Jet
OJ Mayo
Vince
advantage - Centers are giving decent offense, defense, rebounding while the SGs are all
ALIAS Conclusion:
Centers are slightly stronger (because the top tiers have more impact than the lower tiers), mostly off the strength of Dwight + Bynum vs. Kobe + Wade
However, in Tier 3 (abv avg starter level players) there are more quality SGs than centers.
The only way to break the deadlock is to look at future potential. Centers like Cousins, A. Davis, M. Gasol, and R. Hibbert have higher upside than Harden + E. Gordon + OJ Mayo.
Centers by a hair
