Is there really a difference between Ol' Dirty's rap-singing and Young Thug's rap-singing?

Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
270,873
Reputation
67,065
Daps
592,150
Thugger>>> ODB

Neg me into oblivion:yeshrug:

it’s just that ODB gets more love cause he from the East Coast and you know everybody is supposed to love East Coast Artist more than other regions (especially the South) because they started Hip-Hop and hey are REEL RAP (whatever that means)

Do Thug got an album that sound great from start 2 finish like Return To The 36 Chambers and nikka Please, tho? :dame:

Dirty got a classic in Return To The 36 Chambers.
I ain't never heard nobody say Thug got a classic album.

shyt, nikka Please is a personal classic to me. :manny:
 

Trilogy

well, probably not...
Joined
Dec 23, 2016
Messages
2,000
Reputation
-1,205
Daps
4,582
Do Thug got an album that sound great from start 2 finish like Return To The 36 Chambers and nikka Please, tho? :dame:

Dirty got a classic in Return To The 36 Chambers.
I ain't never heard nobody say Thug got a classic album.

shyt, nikka Please is a personal classic to me. :manny:

All I know is that if Thug is trash then so is ODB
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,256
Reputation
17,801
Daps
115,983
It's crazy how Hip Hop has changed so much in some ways.


Thanks, likewise, bruh.
In no way am I trying to disrespect Dirty (he my favorite member outta the Wu).
But I was really trying to look at the comparison between their unorthodox styles of rap singing and be objective about it.
Cause to some degree, everything does get recycled to an extent and then someone puts their spin on it.

"No ideas original" - Nas
theres plenty of dudes who have unorthodox styles..

and, i think Thug actually has some dope joints.. but, to compare the two is laughable to say the least.. Young Thug is a byproduct of Lil Wayne.. theres really no getting around it.. and you really cant even compare those two.. Wayne fathered his whole style.. dude even wanted to name his album after Wayne.. :mjlol:
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
270,873
Reputation
67,065
Daps
592,150
theres plenty of dudes who have unorthodox styles..

and, i think Thug actually has some dope joints.. but, to compare the two is laughable to say the least.. Young Thug is a byproduct of Lil Wayne.. theres really no getting around it.. and you really cant even compare those two.. Wayne fathered his whole style.. dude even wanted to name his album after Wayne.. :mjlol:

True, u right.
I remember when Thug came out and nikkas was like "he this, he that". All I remember thinking was, "this nikka is just Wayne version 2.0". :mjlol:
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,256
Reputation
17,801
Daps
115,983
True, u right.
I remember when Thug came out and nikkas was like "he this, he that". All I remember thinking was, "this nikka is just Wayne version 2.0". :mjlol:


you know even Wayne probably was listening to dude with the straight 'scust face.. :hhh:

funny thing is.. if ODB wore a dress on his album cover.. and, was calling dudes handsome.. you would never hear the end of it from these new cats... folks cant even be consistent with the hate nowadays..:mjlol:
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
270,873
Reputation
67,065
Daps
592,150
you know even Wayne probably was listening to dude with the straight 'scust face.. :hhh:

funny thing is.. if ODB wore a dress on his album cover.. and, was calling dudes handsome.. you would never hear the end of it from these new cats... folks cant even be consistent with the hate nowadays..:mjlol:

Yup.
U know what the whole Wayne and Thug square off reminded me of? Mario and Wario :russ:

And yeah, if ODB had done that shyt... shyt, I don't even wanna think about that. :bryan:
 

BuddahMAC

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
4,104
Reputation
2,862
Daps
17,003
Reppin
NULL
The thing on ODB is he was pure unfiltered ID. Everything he did was purely him.

"My momma taught me this shyt. And my daddy learned from her na-na. Which is gooooood, which is goooooooood."

Now, Dirt was heavily influenced all the music before him and, especially in that first album, you get to hear all those influences come through. The soul music, 70s funk, old school rap, schoolyard snaps, Blowfly, club gigs, radio spots, etc.. but it all came out as ODB's own voice. It could be grating to some, others might have needed a few listens to get what Dirt was doing, but whether you were a fan or not, everyone agrees there's no father to his style.

You look at some of these guys now, and they're jumping on trends, maybe fleshing them into their own lanes, but it's coming straight off of a road that's already established and well-traveled. They're crafting brands and sounds already primed to sell and gain attention on social media. Jumping on a track and autotune singing now when it's already been done by Wayne, Ye, T-Pain, etc... for a decade? That's just piggy-backing trends and not doing your own thing. Young Thug gonna croon filtered over a trap beat? That's identical to 75% of the other new songs dropping.

If there's anything Ason was, it's unique.
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
270,873
Reputation
67,065
Daps
592,150
The thing on ODB is he was pure unfiltered ID. Everything he did was purely him.

"My momma taught me this shyt. And my daddy learned from her na-na. Which is gooooood, which is goooooooood."

Now, Dirt was heavily influenced all the music before him and, especially in that first album, you get to hear all those influences come through. The soul music, 70s funk, old school rap, schoolyard snaps, Blowfly, club gigs, radio spots, etc.. but it all came out as ODB's own voice. It could be grating to some, others might have needed a few listens to get what Dirt was doing, but whether you were a fan or not, everyone agrees there's no father to his style.

You look at some of these guys now, and they're jumping on trends, maybe fleshing them into their own lanes, but it's coming straight off of a road that's already established and well-traveled. They're crafting brands and sounds already primed to sell and gain attention on social media. Jumping on a track and autotune singing now when it's already been done by Wayne, Ye, T-Pain, etc... for a decade? That's just piggy-backing trends and not doing your own thing. Young Thug gonna croon filtered over a trap beat? That's identical to 75% of the other new songs dropping.

If there's anything Ason was, it's unique.

True, great post. :wow:
 
Top