Jay Z top 10 to me, arguably top 5. I don't think he's overrated because he's exhibited enough true greatness to be considered great and 1 of the best.
I don't believe he's the GOAT, Pac, KRS, K-Rino and Nas comfortably better to me, but after that it gets closer because Jay has numerous classic songs and to me 2 classic albums.
At times cause Jay Z last shyt was wack I think some overlook the great work he's done. The other side to me personally he's not near being THE Goat, he's missing some elements but he has mad skill, is a dope writer, made great songs and classic albums. Sometimes hearing him rhyme at his best is an honour, for what he's done he has my respect and appreciation, I still wish he comes back and delivers some better music, even now he can do a lot better than MCHG.