How am I posting opinion? The mf link I provided listed the album sales. You can do the addition (if you can) yourself. She hasn’t gone diamond since Emancipation and none of her releases since have even come close to matching it. And the that’s with an all star lineup of producers.
And the numbers show was even with those producers you listed, she was dropping duds and going platinum off name recognition. She dropped a fukkin greatest hits album around this time that went platinum. Come on dog. By your logic, not even Tommy Mottolla mattered
Tommy Mottolla wasn't making her music. That has nothing to do with what's being posted.
For those of us who know math, her highest selling album worldwide was
before JD. She sold 28,000,000. Right after that, she did the Christmas joint. That did like 18,000,000. After JD came in, he did a couple of songs on the next joint. They did 20,000,000 on it. She was already starting to sell less than the last
actual album. 28, 18, 20. The next album, he wasn't on. Still sold another 10,000,000, lol. He hopped on the one after that, and that one sold LESS!
So again, stars are stars. But everyone is selling less records as time goes on because people stopped
buying as much. You mentioned
Charmbracelet, but JD worked on that album. So which one is it? We give him credit for the successes but not the "flops". On the album you're claiming he saved her on, he was like 1 out of 10-11 producers, which included dudes like Neptunes, Kanye, Rodney Jerkins, Swizz, and mad other people. And I think that did like another 10,000,000 for her worldwide. Which is where she's been multiple times in her career. And not with one producer! So clearly, the ticket to this is that Mariah is a super icon and has a ridiculous following.
JD was on the albums that flopped, just as he was on the ones that worked. And he's only doing 2-4 songs per album. These albums are packed with legends producing. Difference is, she's shown that she doesn't need
one person behind the boards to sell mad records. Because she's done it without that. More than just once.