New flash, a lot of artist don't write every song they've ever made.
Don't understand that last critique, because that's exactly how he got known in the first place.
In Hip Hop you're generally expected to write your songs or have a large hand in writing your songs.
As in someone else can come up with the hook, someone else can make the beat,
someone else can sing/rap the hook, etc. but ultimately it's supposed to be "your song"
and thus you should have done the lion's share of the work.
Producer rappers like ye, dre and diddy are given some leeway since producing is
their expertise but if the rapper/producer isn't really doing anything like they assume for
Kanyethen people think there really isn't a point in giving Kanye praise for what comes
out of those sessions.
I honestly have no idea how much is or isn't written by Kanye but I think I'd be disappointed if he
was basically hands off the entire project, only to come in and finish the album by walking into the studio to rap over someone else's rough drafts.